17/18
Taylor Hill/Getty Images, Jordi Vidal/Redferns via Getty Images
While everyone was anticipating the four-time Oscar nominee's supposed wedding to financial consultant Andrew Youmans, she up and pulled a fast one—meeting, falling for and marrying singer-songwriter Elverum in a months-long span earlier this year. The Venom star, 38, divulged their plans to hold a small, private wedding in the Adirondacks during a Vanity Fair interview, knowing that by the time the September issue hit stands, she and the Mount Eerie artist, 40, would already be legally entwined. It represented the happiest of endings for the mom of 13-year-old Matilda, who lost ex Heath Ledger to a 2008 drug overdose. As she told the mag, "I never gave up on love."