Isaac Brekken/Getty Images for Cirque du Soleil
While still appearing as McKinley High's beloved Coach Beiste, the 59-year-old actress put on a show of her own in December 2013. Inviting friends and loved ones to their L.A. home for a holiday party, she and girlfriend Bridgett Casteen (engaged two months earlier at Disneyland) surprised guests with news they were actually attending a wedding.
A decade on, the retired athlete and actress is still Jones' forever crush. As she once posted on Instagram, "I LOVE YOU WHOLE HEARTEDLY BABE."