Watch with Kristin
It's more fun than doing it alone
American Idol Tweaks Judging Process Again
FOX
As the old adage goes: If it ain't broke, don't fix it. American Idol will go back to its usual way of judging the contestants—each judge gives a critique—on Tuesday night's performance show, according to a set source.
Last week, in an attempt to keep from going over its allotted time as it had the week before, the producers opted for "judging in pairs," in which Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul would judge one contestant, and Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi would judge the next contestant, and so on.
Fans were not pleased...
Across the Internet, Idol fans lit up the message boards against the new way of judging. Watch With Kristin's own poll showed 68.2 percent of the fans voting against voting in pairs and saying they want to hear what all four judges have to say about each performance.
That said, fans who took our poll also voted on which judge they can do without, and the results were surprising (Paula Abdul and Kara DioGuardi, neck in neck?!)
Which judge can you do without?
Kara DioGuardi, 44.3 percent
Paula Abdul, 35.7 percent
Randy Jackson, 17.4 percent
Simon Cowell, 2.6 percent
Are you happy the show's returning to normal on Tuesday?
Most Commented
- Is Ugly Betty Ending? And Who Gets the Girl? (402)
- Jon and Kate Are Back on TV Tonight; Will You Watch? (161)
- Backstage at DWTS: Joanna Admits Her Shocking Elimination "Sucks" (147)
- Hilary Duff Is Gone From Gossip Girl; Find Out Who's Hooking Up Next! (133)
- Spoiler Chat: Grey's Anatomy's Kevin McKidd Dishes on (And Defends!) "Love Triangle" (125)
- Grey's Anatomy Love Triangle: "The Characters Can't Be Happy All the Time" (90)
- Glee Sneak Peeks: "Wanna See a Real-Life Music Video"? (75)
- Did Christian Siriano Just Spill the Winner of Tonight's Project Runway Finale?! (65)
- Does God Save the Supernatural Boys? (57)
- This Just In: Lost and Chuck Get Premiere Dates (51)
Get Kristin Anywhere
Subscribe to the Watch with Kristin RSS feed »
New to RSS feeds? Learn more »
For breaking-news alerts, text WWK to 44636 Learn more »
Our Partners
Email Kristin
Got a burning TV question, a comment or hot dish about your fave TV show? Email your Q's to tvdiva@eonline.com, and then check the next chat for answers!
73 Comments
-
Show the next 1 - 0 of 73 comments
Now loading...