9/9
Maarten de Boer/ABC via Getty Images
Listen, would it be unexpected for the producers to pick the lawyer/influencer, who briefly met Peter Weber before filming, was surprisingly sent home before hometowns and then went on to date the pilot for a year after his s--tshow season ended in disaster. Undoubtedly yes. However, there is no denying the allure of a curveball, which is what choosing the 30-year-old would definitely be for the franchise. Plus, with over 800,000 Instagram followers, she has by far the biggest social media reach of anyone on this list.
And last year, when one of her fans asked if she serve as Bachelorette if the role was offered, Kelley replied, "I would definitely consider it."