Inside the Undying Fascination With Sharon Tate: Destined for Stardom, Doomed to Be a Legend

It took years after pregnant actress Sharon Tate and six others were murdered by the Manson "family" for the slain star to return to the center of her own story.

By Natalie Finn Jan 24, 2023 11:00 AMTags
Watch: Margot Robbie Wore Sharon Tate's Jewelry On Set

"I don't like that word starlet at all, because there's no such thing, actually," Sharon Tate said in 1966.

"I feel, at least in my estimation, that every person, if they want to be an actress or they want to stay in the acting world—which is a pretty tough world—before you even make an appearance, it's very necessary to learn your craft first, and take as much time, and do as much as you can."

At the time, she was a stunning up-and-comer who moved to Hollywood with big dreams, which she hoped were on the verge of panning out.

Three years later, she became more famous than anyone's wildest ambitions—or worst nightmares—could have imagined.

19 Things You Didn't Know About Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

The actress had a handful of B-movies, the most memorable being Valley of the Dolls, and some TV guest spots to her name when, at 26 years old and eight-and-a-half months pregnant, she was one of seven people murdered by members of Charles Manson's so-called "family" over the course of two nights of carnage that shook Hollywood.

Globe Photos/Shutterstock

More than five decades later, Tate—who would have turned 80 on Jan. 24—remains frozen in time, the unwitting star of one of the most gripping, gruesome and parsed-over crime dramas to worm its way into the fabric of our culture. Her story has often been a footnote to Manson's, however, her life a casualty all over again when weighed against the insane details of what he and his followers did.

A thorough portrayal of Tate's life, in which she's back to being the star of her own story, has yet to occur onscreen, but Quentin Tarantino did set out to remedy history with Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood, which ends with Tate alive and well, her would-be killers vanquished by the actor (Leonardo DiCaprio) who lives next door, his devoted stuntman (Brad Pitt, in an Oscar-winning turn) and a really good girl named Brandy (Sayuri, an American Pit Bull Terrier).

Globe Photos Inc/REX/Shutterstock; Andrew Cooper/Sony Pictures

Margot Robbie doesn't have tons to say in the film, but she still commanded the screen as Tate, her kind eyes wide with hope and excitement for the future. A future that she still has in Tarantino's version of events.

"Even when I was doing something as mundane as walking down the street, he would set up 100 feet of track, or a crane—or whatever it was, it was always a really extravagant, amazing shot, and that never really happens on film sets," Robbie told E! News at the movie's 2019 premiere. "It was pretty spectacular."

On Today in 2019, Robbie noted that, before she played Tate, "whenever I heard her name I really only thought about her death. I was never really exposed to the parts of her life when she was alive."

Sony Pictures

Meanwhile, there has been no cease in the telling and retelling of Manson's story, how the diminutive career criminal from Ohio got people to kill for him and how he held sway over countless others.

No true crime renaissance was needed to bring the interest in that back. The focus on bad people and the terrible things they've done has yet to go out of fashion. But at least there's room in this sprawling storytelling landscape of ours to remember the lives that actually deserve remembering.

"In 1969 my sister was involved in an event that changed the country in ways that still resonate," her sister Debra Tate wrote in the introduction to the 2014 book Sharon Tate Recollection, featuring dozens of photos of the late star. "That said, I always felt it was very unfair for her life to be remembered primarily for its final moments. Sharon had a magnificent life."

The events of the early morning hours of Aug. 9 and Aug. 10, 1969—which came to be referred to in homicide parlance as the Tate-LaBianca murders—effectively muted whatever rosy glow left over from the "Summer of Love" may still have been lingering in the 1960s. For Sharon Tate, it had been the decade in which everything had happened, and everything ended.

TV's Most Killer True Crime Transformations

The eldest of Col. Paul Tate and Doris Tate's three daughters, Sharon was born in Texas—at 6 months old she was crowned Miss Tiny Tot of Dallas after her grandma submitted photos of her—but the family moved around frequently as dictated by Paul's Army career. At 16, she was Miss Richland, Washington, then Queen of the Autorama at a car show. She moved to Verona, Italy, with her parents and sisters Debra and Patricia in 1960.

She went to an American high school, where she was a cheerleader and prom queen in 1961. According to a jarring mention in Ed Sanders' 2016 biography Sharon Tate: A Life, Tate told Roman Polanski on their first date that she was raped by a soldier in Italy when she was 17, but as Polanski put it, she said the attack "'hadn't left her emotionally scarred.'" 

Knowing already that she wanted to be an actress, she would seek out the sets of film shoots in the area, and she ended up an extra in the swords-and-sandals epic Barabbas. Her mother allowed one of the film's stars, Jack Palance, to take her out on a dinner date. Gossip columnist Hedda Hopper also linked a 19-year-old Tate to Richard Beymer, who had just filmed the role of Tony in West Side Story and was shooting Adventures of a Young Man in Verona.

In the summer of 1961, Tate's father was assigned to San Pedro, Calif. She beat her parents to Southern California by a few months to get a head start on her aspirations.

13 Crimes That Shocked the World and Changed Our Culture Forever

"You must remember," she told interviewer Robert Musel a few years later, "that I was shy and bashful when I reached Hollywood. My parents were very strict with me. I didn't smoke or anything. I only had just enough money to get by and I hitchhiked a ride on a truck to the office of an agent whose name I had. That very first day he sent me to the cigarette commercial job. A girl showed me how it should be done, you know taking a deep, deep breath and look ecstatic."

Eventually she passed out from too many puffs. "That ended my career in cigarette commercials," she laughed.

When Tate was 20, she auditioned for what become Petticoat Junction, and was brought to the attention of Martin Ransohoff, executive producer of The Beverly Hillbillies. He and partner John Calley signed Tate to a seven-year contract. Tate recalled him actually saying to her, "'Baby, we're going to make you a star.'"

Her agent negotiated a salary of $750 a month for her and she moved into the all-women Hollywood Studio Club, the onetime home of Marilyn Monroe, Kim Novak, Rita Moreno and many more familiar names.

True Crime on Film

In 1963, according to what Tate's mother would later tell police about her daughter's life, she had been involved with a French actor who at one point beat her up so badly she needed to go to the hospital. Biographer Sanders writes about Tate's relationship with Philippe Forquet, whom she lived with in New York while briefly studying acting with Lee Strasberg. They returned to L.A. supposedly engaged, though there was some doubt that they were that serious, that it may have been the studio system at work whipping up publicity. After reports surfaced that he put her in the hospital, Forquet said that Tate cut him in the chest with a broken wine bottle.

In 1964 she met hairstylist Jay Sebring, who had recently separated from his wife. He and Tate dated, and eventually lived together, until she fell for Polanski when he directed her in The Fearless Vampire Killers.

While she was being groomed for bigger things, Ransohoff would have his new future star wear a black wig (so she wouldn't be recognized yet) and appear in a bit role on The Beverly Hillbillies to get her used to being on camera. In the old-school studio system, it was common for promising talent to basically sign away their professional (and oftentimes personal) lives to the studio or production company, in exchange for the promise of a career.

By the 1960s, it wasn't as common, but that was the experience Tate was having. In fact, without her having done anything particularly noteworthy onscreen yet, European papers were calling her "the next Marilyn Monroe."

Ezio Praturlon/Shutterstock

"Well, it's very strenuous, I must say," Tate said in a 1966 interview when asked what the process had been like for her. "For approximately three years, I've had no personal life, I guess you could call it. I've done nothing but study from 8 o'clock in the morning till about 6:30 at night. Then on three evenings out of every week I went to a night class, too.

"I had acting classes, voice, singing, body building—everything, absolutely everything. Which is necessary, you know."

Asked by the interviewer if, having been toiling away like that, she felt like a "prisoner" of the system, Tate said no. 

"Never, not really," she replied. "I felt that, if you're serious about it, it's a lot of hard work. If not, you play and you get absolutely nowhere at all." 

She laughed heartily at the Marilyn comparisons. "Oh, dear," she shook her head. "I love Marilyn Monroe, but it would be kind of difficult for me to be another Marilyn Monroe, I think." Asked if she saw herself being subjected to similar pressures as the late star, who had died in 1962 of a barbiturate overdose, Tate replied again, "Oh, dear. In my estimation that kind of a sex symbol is really gone. It's more imagination. Sexiness to me is part of every movement. You don't see the big low-cut dresses anymore, it's more all to the imagination."


Until then her film work consisted of commercials and uncredited roles, such as "Beautiful Girl" in The Americanization of Emily, which Ransohoff produced, that seemingly ended up on the cutting room floor. She and the black wig had been on 15 episodes of The Beverly Hillbillies and she had appeared on The Man From U.N.C.L.E. and Mister Ed.

She had one of her most personally enriching experiences when she went to Big Sur to shoot a bit role in The Sandpiper with Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, and she loved the coastal enclave so much it's where she would return time and again to decompress.

But the world was about to meet Sharon Tate—the earnest, dedicated, blond Sharon Tate.

She appeared in four movies that came out in 1967, three Ransohoff-produced films—Eye of the DevilDon't Make Waves and the horror spoof The Fearless Vampire Killers—and the coup de grâce, Valley of the Dolls, adapted in rapid fashion from Jacqueline Susann's best-selling 1966 novel that also made the author an overnight sensation.

20th Century Fox/Kobal/Shutterstock

As Tate was being interviewed aboard the Princess Italia after the film's world premiere, as the yacht sailed from Italy to California as part of a splashy promotional campaign, she was the big breakout star of the moment. She was nominated for a Golden Globe in 1968, Most Promising Newcomer (she lost to The Graduate star Katharine Ross) and quickly booked two more films, The Wrecking Crew and 12+1, featuring wildly different co-stars in Dean Martin and Orson Welles.

She also got married.

Tate first met Roman Polanski in 1966 when she was in London filming Eye of the Devil. The Oscar-nominated filmmaker, born in Paris and raised in Poland, where he lost his mother in the Holocaust, was coming off the critical and commercial success of his first English-language film, the 1965 psychological thriller Repulsion starring Catherine Deneuve. He had already made a name for himself in Europe—as a visionary and as a playboy.

Action! Actresses Who Fell for Directors

Polanski had been married before, to Polish actress Barbara Kwiatkowska-Lass, and he showed no signs of wanting to settle down again, even as he pursued Tate throughout the filming of The Fearless Vampire Killers. He also photographed her semi-nude for Playboy during the shoot. 

When Sebring went to visit Tate in London after they wrapped, she told him she had fallen in love with Polanski, which he seemed to accept, though friends suspected he still harbored feelings for the actress.

Heartbreak didn't seem to hinder Sebring's dating life, however—he's said to have been an inspiration for Warren Beatty's playboy hairdresser in Shampoo. 


When they first met, "I thought she was quite pretty, but I wasn't at that time very impressed," Polanski later told detectives at Parker Center, headquarters of the Los Angeles Police Department, after his wife was killed. "But then I saw her again. I took her out. We talked a lot, you know. At that time I was really swinging. All I was interested in was to f--k a girl and move on."

He didn't start sleeping with Tate, he said, until a few months into shooting The Fearless Vampire Killers. "She was so sweet and so lovely that I didn't believe it, you know," he marveled to police. "I'd had bad experiences and I didn't believe people like that existed."

How the Cast of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood Compares to the Real-Life Players

While waiting for the other shoe to drop, he realized that Tate was as good of a person as she seemed. "She was fantastic," he recalled. "She loved me." And she gave him the space that, despite being enamored with her, he apparently still needed.

"I said, 'You know how I am; I screw around.' And she said, 'I don't want to change you.' She was ready to do everything, just to be with me. She was a f--king angel. She was a unique character, who I'll never meet again in my life."

As far as the spurned Jay Sebring was concerned, Polanski said, "I'm sure in the beginning of our relationship there was still his love for Sharon, but I think that largely it disappeared. I'm quite sure." 

Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images

When Polanski and Tate married in London on Jan. 20, 1968, he was about to have a hit on his hands with Rosemary's Baby, his adaptation of Ira Levin's book, the biggest-selling horror novel of the 1960s, starring Mia Farrow, John Cassavetes and Ruth Gordon, who'd win a Supporting Actress Oscar for her turn as the neighbor from Hell.

The film premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in May 1968, and there are photographs of Tate living it up with her husband, Farrow and assorted other jet-setters.

Tate is said to have asked Ransohoff to let her out of her contract not long after the Princess Italia docked, saying she wanted to be a full-time wife and, eventually, mother—but her Golden Globe nomination, the success of Rosemary's Baby and more exciting happenings prevented her from pressing the issue.


By the time she got pregnant at the end of 1968, there was already speculation that Tate was hanging hopes of saving her already-floundering marriage upon the baby. Some of their friends said she waited to tell Polanski she was pregnant until it was too late for her to have an abortion.

"I guess I kind of live in a fairy tale world," she's quoted in Restless Souls, by Alisa Statman and Sharon's niece Brie Tate, one of her sister Patti's daughters. "We have a good arrangement; Roman lies and I pretend to believe him."

At the same time, when they had a chance to nest together in L.A. (she convinced him to at least rent a home, resisting his excuse that he liked being able to pack up and leave a place anytime he wanted) they were happy. After a bungalow at Chateau Marmont proved not to be the kind of home base she had in mind, they spent several months renting her Valley of the Dolls co-star Patty Duke's house.

Summer of '69: When Charles Manson Scared the Hell Out of Hollywood

In early 1969, Tate and Polanski rented 10050 Cielo Drive, nestled off of Benedict Canyon by the upscale neighborhood of Bel Air. They made the deal over the phone with the house's outgoing tenant, record producer Terry Melcher. The home's owner, Rudy Altobelli, hired a live-in caretaker named William Garretson to look after the property. Garretson lived in the guest house behind the gated main residence, a sprawling French country-style home.

It seemed entirely inconsequential at the time, but Melcher had recently been unimpressed by the music of aspiring singer-songwriter Charles Manson, whom he'd met through Beach Boy Dennis Wilson, who had met Charlie after picking up some hitchhiking female members of the "family." Melcher later remembered Manson being in the car one night when Wilson gave him a ride home when he was living at Cielo Drive.

Tate, who was filming 12+1, and Polanski were in Europe that March when their friends Abigail Folger and Voytek Frykowski moved into the Cielo Drive house. Tate returned alone from Europe in July via ocean liner because she was too far along in her pregnancy to fly, and the couple planned to stay with her until Polanski returned for the birth of their baby.

On the night of Aug. 8, the three of them and Sebring went out to El Coyote Cafe, a Mexican restaurant on Beverly Boulevard that remains open to this day.

They all went back to the house on Cielo Drive after dinner. Folger was supposed to fly up to San Francisco the next morning to see her mother.

AP Photo/File

Housekeeper Winifred Chapman found the bodies the next morning—all four friends and 18-year-old Steven Parent, who was just leaving when Charles "Tex" Watson, Susan Atkins, Patricia Krenwinkel and Linda Kasabian (the prosecution's eventual star witness) arrived. Parent, who worked part-time at a stereo shop and was there to see if the caretaker Garretson wanted to buy some equipment, was shot dead in his car. Garretson would briefly be a suspect, because he was alive and well and in the guest house when police arrived on the scene.

Authorities contacted Polanski's friend and business manager, William Tennant, who was on the tennis court when he got the call, and he went to the house and identified Tate, Frykowski, Folger and Sebring, but had no idea who the young man in the car was.

He was the one to call Polanski, who was in London finishing production on The Day of the Dolphin

As relayed in Vincent Bugliosi's Helter Skelter, the best-selling true crime book of all time, Tennant said, "Roman, there's been a disaster in a house...Your house. Sharon is dead, and Voytek and Gibby and Jay." The filmmaker was in disbelief and asked how it had happened. He thought perhaps a fire. Not a massacre.

AP Photo, File

Tate was in a floral-printed camisole and matching underpants when she was stabbed 16 times, five of them wounds that would have been fatal on their own. A rope was looped around her neck, strung over a rafter above, and the other end was wrapped twice around Sebring's neck. Atkins wrote "pig" on the front door in Tate's blood.

Sebring, whose real name was Thomas John Kummer, had been living in another Benedict Canyon home, on Easton Drive, that had once belonged to actress Jean Harlow, who died at 26 due to complications of kidney failure (which conspiracy theory has attributed to everything from hair dye poisoning to a botched abortion). More eerily, Harlow's husband, producer Paul Bern, committed suicide in her bedroom two months after they got married. 

People who knew Sebring told Bugliosi he had bought the house because of its "far out" reputation. He owned a salon on Fairfax Avenue in L.A. and had just opened a shop in San Francisco in May 1969, step one of his plan to open numerous locations and launch a line of men's grooming products. He was stabbed seven times and shot once.

Folger, an heiress to the Folgers Coffee fortune, was a debutante and Radcliffe graduate who had driven from New York to L.A. with Frykowski, a twice-married father of one, whom she met in 1968. He was a friend of Polanski's from Poland; his father had financed one of the director's early films and Voytek played a thief in his short film Mammals. That's how Folger met Tate and Sebring, even investing in the burgeoning Sebring International. She was a volunteer social worker for the L.A. County Welfare Department up until the day before she and Frykowski moved into 10050 Cielo Drive.

Depressed and disillusioned by all the suffering she had seen in the course of her work, and using a lot of drugs with Frykowski, she apparently told her psychiatrist—whom she saw every weekday afternoon—on Friday, Aug. 8, that she was thinking of breaking up with her boyfriend.

Biggest Unsolved Murder Mysteries

While processing the crime scene, authorities found 6.9 grams of marijuana in a baggie in a living room cabinet. There were 30 grams of hashish in the nightstand in the bedroom where Frykowski and Folger were staying, along with 10 pills that turned out to be amphetamines—all of which served to fuel wild speculation that the murders were the result of a drug deal gone wrong, or that someone had freaked out during a drug-fueled bacchanal.

Folger, who was stabbed 28 times, had 2.4 milligrams of MDA in her system, while Frykowski had .6 milligrams in his. 

Voytek would tell people he was a writer, but mainly he had ideas about what to do next. "He had no means of support and lived off Folger's fortune," investigators noted in their report, but he was apparently the life of many a drug party. He was shot twice, struck in the head 13 times and stabbed 51 times.

Polanski later told police that his wife had used LSD over a dozen times, mostly before they met, but otherwise did nothing but smoke pot. "And during her pregnancy there was no question," he said. "She was so in love with her pregnancy she would do nothing. I'd pour a glass of wine and she wouldn't touch it."

Your True Crime Obsessions: The Latest Case Updates You Need to Know About

Asked later why they went to that particular house that night, Susan Atkins recalled to authorities that Tex told them they were "going to a house up on the hill that used to belong to Terry Melcher, and the only reason why we were going to that house was because Tex knew the outline of the house."

Their mission once they got there: "To get all of their money and to kill whoever was there."

AP Photo/George Brich

When Polanski arrived in L.A., he was immediately bombarded with questions about his rumored marital troubles. He insisted he had only stayed behind in London to work on his movie, that he was planning to be in L.A. for the birth of his first child.

The funeral for Sharon Tate and their unborn baby, Paul Richard Polanski, was held on Aug. 13 at Holy Cross Cemetery.

More than 150 people came, including Beatty, Kirk Douglas, Steve McQueen, Peter Sellers and John and Michelle Phillips of the Mamas and the Papas. Mia Farrow was said to be too distraught to go to the service, and numerous celebrities were reportedly terrified, wondering if the killings would continue and famous people would be targeted. McQueen started keeping a gun under the front seat of his car. 

Sebring was laid to rest at Forest Lawn, with many of the same mourners in attendance, as well as other clients and friends such as Paul Newman and Henry and Peter Fonda.

AP Photo

There was no internet to fan the flames, but rumors still spread like wildfire in the early days of the investigation, before law enforcement announced in December that they had the people who were responsible for the Tate murders, as well as the similarly brutal Aug. 10 murders of Leno and Rosemary LaBianca, in custody.

Jumpers of the gun started connecting phantom dots between the dark themes and violence depicted in Polanski's films and the ritualistic aspects of the murders. There was speculation that Tate and her pals were devil worshipers, or they had been having some sort of orgy that went wrong, or at the very least Tate had been having sex with Sebring, her old boyfriend. False information about the nature of the wounds and the positioning of the bodies made the rounds. Polanski allowed a photographer from Life magazine to accompany him when he returned to the house for the first time, which struck some as a rather tasteless thing to do.

On Aug. 19 Polanski called a press conference to defend his wife's honor, and his own. (He was still eight years away from the sexual assault conviction that prompted him to flee the U.S. and never return.)

Calling Sharon "beautiful" and a "good person," he said, "the last few years I spent with her were the only time of true happiness in my life."

Sarah Morris/Getty Images

Tate's mother, Doris, spent the rest of her life as an advocate for the rights of victims and their families, and Debra, for years the de facto spokesperson for the family, has been committed to seeing that her sister's killers remain in prison.

Manson, Atkins, Watson, Krenwinkel and Leslie Van Houten, who participated in the LaBianca killings, were originally all sentenced to death, but a temporary moratorium on the death penalty in California that began in 1972 resulted in their sentences being converted to life in prison.

Atkins died of cancer in 2009. Krenwinkel was denied 14 times before a parole board recommended her release in October 2022, but California Gov. Gavin Newsom blocked the decision, saying she "currently poses an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety." Five panels have recommended Van Houten's release since 2016 but either former California Gov. Jerry Brown or his successor, Newsom, overruled the decision each time, including in March 2022.

Manson, who never stopped insisting that he didn't tell anybody to commit murder for him, while still spouting his half-cocked theories about whatever was grinding his gears, died in November 2017. 

Cold Justice Is Back to Tackle More Horrific Unsolved Murders in New Trailer

Grace Van Dien played Tate in Mary Harron's 2019 film Charlie Says, but it's mainly about how Manson, played by Matt Smith of The Crown and House of the Dragon fame, manipulated his "family" members. The Haunting of Sharon Tate, meanwhile, was all about the actress, but used true events as only a jumping-off point. 

And it took too far of a leap, for some.

Debra Tate voiced her displeasure at the movie's concept, which is that the doomed actress was receiving subliminal messages and foresaw her fate, and that of her friends. The filmmakers purport to have been inspired by an interview Tate gave in 1968, in which she mentioned having a dream about being murdered by cult members.

Hulton Archive/Getty Images

"It doesn't matter who it is acting in it—it's just tasteless," Debra told People in 2018. "It's classless how everyone is rushing to release something for the 50th anniversary of this horrific event."

"I know for a fact she did not have a premonition—awake or in a dream—that she and Jay would have their throat cut," she added. "I checked with all of her living friends. None of her friends had any knowledge of this. Tacky, tacky, tacky."

But the film's star, Hilary Duff, who didn't say much about the project leading up to its release in April, wrote in 2018 on Instagram after production wrapped, "Had the incredible opportunity of playing Sharon Tate the past two weeks in an independent movie. She was an amazing woman and it was a true honor." 

As for most takes on the murders, Debra—who had endorsed a biopic that was going to star Kate Bosworth—said, "It's been exploitative since day one. It's been the case since the media went crazy and has perpetuated mistruths making things even more salacious. It's now morphed into something that is more fictionalized than truth at this point. To celebrate the killers and the darkest portion of society as being sexy or acceptable in any way, shape or form is just perpetuating the worst of our society. I am vehemently opposed to anything that does that. I've been dealing with this for 50 years now.

"We need to stop this, and I intend to help the family behind the No Notoriety [a movement to not circulate names and photos of killers] any way I can to help make this a national movement."

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood London Premiere: Red Carpet Fashion

But Debra Tate ultimately came around on Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood, easily the most reverential depiction of Sharon onscreen in 2019. 

Manson, played by Damon Herriman, is only briefly glimpsed, and Robbie's Tate largely runs parallel to the saga of her next-door neighbor, DiCaprio's fading TV star Rick Dalton, and his stuntman/errand guy/devoted buddy Cliff Booth, played by Pitt.

"I'm barely on set with them," Robbie previously acknowledged. 

But the actress spent a lot of time with Tate, aided in her cause by Debra, whom Tarantino talked to beforehand to assuage her fears that her sister would once again be grist for the Manson mill. At one point the movie's release was going to coincide more exactly with the 50th anniversary of the murders in August 2019, but all involved agreed to fast-track the date by a couple of weeks.

Sony Pictures

"This movie is not what people would expect it to be when you combine the Tarantino and Manson names," Debra told TMZ in 2018 after meeting with the director. She ended up loaning Robbie a few pieces of Sharon's jewelry and a partially used bottle of her perfume.

"Wearing some of the pieces of her jewelry and spending time with her sister definitely made me feel closer to her in a way that I don't think I could have without, you know," Robbie told E! News at the premiere. "Reading things and watching things can only really get you so far, but having that personal connection meant a lot to me."

The actress, who was nominated for an Oscar in 2017 for her portrayal of Tonya Harding in I, Tonya, admitted that it was "sometimes very sad to be that closely connected with real-life Sharon. It would kind of hit you at moments, suddenly the tragedy of it all would kind of hit you and you would be tremendously sad."

After seeing the film at the premiere, Debra told Vanity Fair about Robbie, "She made me cry because she sounded just like Sharon. The tone in her voice was completely Sharon, and it just touched me so much that big tears [started falling]. The front of my shirt was wet. I actually got to see my sister again...nearly 50 years later."

She continued, "The thing that touched me the most—it wasn't that Leo and Brad were such famous movie stars. It was Margot, and who she was and her qualities, and the potential to place Sharon and really give it to an audience." Sharon "was so sweet and so kind, intelligent, and lighter than the air in every way... And Margot did a beautiful job at portraying that."

Overall, Debra said, Robbie "actually touched me in a way that convinced me that she was Sharon. She did such a damn good job that, for me, personally, the visit was a little short. I had Sharon back in front of me again, and it was too short a visit."

(Earlier versions of this story were published April 5, 2019, at 3 a.m. PT and Aug. 9, 2019, at 3 a.m. PT)

For more true crime updates on your need-to-know cases, head to