Peter Pan casting

Getty Images, Wireimage

That ticking sound you hear is not the Tic Toc Croc, but something far more ominous: Time running out on the casting of Peter Pan Live!

PPL! (not to be confused with PLL) is down to the wire on casting, needing to lock in actors as the rehearsal dates are, well, apparently, here. NBC president Bob Greenblatt previously said rehearsals would begin Aug. 5 and...Yikes! The cast is far from full.

So far, only three roles have been cast:  Allison Williams as Peter, Christopher Walken as Captain Hook and Christian Boyle as Smee/Father Darling.

Not a peep yet about Wendy, Michael, John, Tiger Lily, Nana, etc…

But fear not! We are here to help. And so are you. We've put together the greatest casting minds we know, and have come up with this list of who we feel would be the best contenders for the remaining roles for Peter Pan Live!, set to air Dec. 4 on NBC.

Now it's your turn to weigh in and VOTE!

Who would be the best actor for each of these remaining Peter Pan Live! roles?

VOTE NOW!

Peter Pan casting, Wendy

Getty Images, Disney

Wendy
WENDY: Playing age 13/14, on the verge of adolescence. Dance skills. Stong singing skills.

This poll is closed

21.7
25.7
15.7
10.7
26.3
Peter Pan casting, Tiger Lily

Getty Images, Disney

Tiger Lily
TIGER LILY: Small, attractive/sexy, athletic. Very good dancer. Vocally strong.

This poll is closed

47.9
3.6
9.2
17.4
22.0
Tinkerbell, Peter Pan Casting

Getty Images, Disney

Tinkerbell
TINKERBELL: Traditionally played by a flashing light, but NBC might want more star power!

This poll is closed

43.5
6.3
36.7
7.0
6.5
Peter Pan casting, Mrs. Darling

Getty Images, Disney

Mrs. Darling
MRS. DARLING: Playing late 30?s. Tallish, graceful, warm, mortherly. Vocally strong.

This poll is closed

11.1
14.0
53.0
8.7
13.1
Peter Pan Casting, Indian Chief

Getty Images; Disney

Indian Chief
INDIAN CHIEF: Tall, manly, splendid physique. -Rich bass baritone voice. Good dancer.

This poll is closed

27.3
11.7
17.0
21.9
22.1
Peter Pan casting, Nana the Dog

Getty Images, Disney

Nana
NANA THE DOG: Strong, athletic, good singer.

This poll is closed

11.7
12.5
23.8
13.4
38.7
Peter Pan Casting, Tik Toc Croc

Getty Images; Disney

Tic Toc Croc
TIC TOC CROC: Anyone you?d want to see crawl around in a croc suit!

This poll is closed

15.7
4.4
12.1
43.9
23.8
Peter Pan Casting, John

Getty Images; Disney

John
JOHN: Playing age 12 (could be older). Strong singer. A good-looking boy, bespectacled.

This poll is closed

16.6
13.0
44.3
13.7
12.4
Peter Pan Casting, Michael

Getty Images; Disney

Michael
MICHAEL: Child actor. Playing age 7/8. Sweet, bubbly, likeable boy, full of fun. Must be able to sing well.

This poll is closed

19.6
11.0
13.6
20.9
34.9
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share