Apparently, you're not really feelin' Johnny Depp.
Based on your numerous comments and clicks on our poll this morning, many of you agree with People's pick for Sexiest Man Alive, but a majority of you would have gone in a different direction.
Well, we hear you loud and clear...and you're not alone.
"I'm a bit surprised," a taken-aback America's Next Top Model judge "Miss J" Alexander told us at the VH1 Save the Music Big Shopping event at the W Hotel Times Square this afternoon.
We read what you had to say about this hot-button issue and tallied your first choices (yeah, we're that scientific from time to time). We're not going to lie—you surprised us.
Your hottest hottie, by a landslide, is...
True Blood's Alexander Skarsgård!
Get him and more in Your Hottest Hotties gallery of suggested studs, in descending order of popularity based on your—yes, your!—comments.