RETURNS
AUG 29, 8PM
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Heidi Klum, Stacy Keibler

Andrew H. Walker, Jeff Schear/Getty Images

Fashion Police logo 80x80

They don't call Heidi Klum "The Body" for nothing. But looks like Stacy Keibler is giving the supermodel a run for her money nickname.

Few celebs can wear skintight leather as successfully as these two ladies, which makes this competition all that much stiffer.

We're not in love with the '70s vibe that the new America's Got Talent judge is sporting. The long sleeves and belt make her look like a Charlie's Angels extra!

On the other hand, Stacy's pointy white pumps contrasted with that body-hugging fuscia frock are equally outdated. This is one battle that's almost too close to call.

So you do: Tell us, who wore it best?!