Never have we been so scared of latex, especially after he impregnated Vivien with what is surely a demon-baby.
What sealed the deal that AHS was going to freak us out every week? The fact that even the promos were tripping us out.
We dubbed American Horror Story show "the scariest show on television" back when we screened the pilot, and it only got crazier from there!
PHOTOS: Spookiest Shows on TV