Shocker: Jack and Jill Not Adam Sandler's Worst Movie This Year!

Comedy avoids Bucky Larson disaster with $26 mil at weekend box office, and (wow!) 3 percent fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes; Immortals takes No. 1 spot

By Joal Ryan Nov 13, 2011 5:52 PMTags
Adam Sandler, Jack and JillColumbia Pictures

Yes, the new Superman passed his first big box-office test. And, yes, Leonardo DiCaprio's latest Oscar vehicle got off OK.

But, no, Jack and Jill did not end up as the worst-reviewed, worst-performing Adam Sandler movie of the year.

Not even close. 

Jack and Jill bowed in second place in the weekend standings with an estimated Friday-Sunday take of $26 million, on the low end of the scale for Sandler comedies, but not on the lowest Little Nicky end. The bottom line: Not great, not a disaster.

The cross-dressing comedy, starring Sandler and (wait for it…) Sandler, dodged another bullet when it rallied, so to speak, to post a 3 percent critical rating on Rotten Tomatoes, up from its inglorious 0 percent on Friday

Put 'em all together, and Jack and Jill was no Bucky Larson: Born to Be a Star. That quickly forgotten Sandler-produced and -cowritten comedy from September opened to just $1.4 million nationwide, and earned an irredeemable goose egg from movie reviewers.

Immortals, meanwhile, put upcoming Man of Steel star Henry Cavill at No. 1. The $75 million battle epic grossed $32 million, and another $36 million overseas. The haul here was bigger than expected, and maybe even surprisingly strong considering the real-world competition posed by Saturday night's high-profile boxing and mixed-martial arts bouts.

DiCaprio's J. Edgar, the biopic of the FBI legend/tyrant which paired the star for the first time with Clint Eastwood, who directed, earned $11.5 million, up from Eastwood's last wide-release, awards-season offering, 2009's Invictus. (For those keeping score at home, J. Edgar actually opened in limited release on Wednesday, but moved onto nearly 2,000 screens on Friday.)

Elsewhere, the family-friendly toon Puss in Boots dropped from No. 1 to third, but otherwise held nicely, and passed the $100 million mark overall.

In its second weekend, Tower Heist became old news just like the Brett Ratner-Eddie Murphy Oscars, and fell to fourth. So far, the $75 million comedy has lumbered its way to about $44 million domestically.

Brad Pitt's Moneyball, one of the success stories of the fall, exited the Top 10 after a solid seven-weekend stay. The $50 million baseball movie has grossed about $72 million here.

George Clooney and Ryan Gosling's The Ides of March also dropped from the Top 10. The political lasted five weekends, and came away with just under $40 million—all in all, pretty good for a grownup political thriller that reputedly cost about $12.5 million. 

Here's a complete look at the weekend's top movies, as compiled from the studios' domestic estimates and Exhibitor Relations stats:

  1. Immortals, $32 million
  2. Jack and Jill, $26 million
  3. Puss in Boots, $25.5 million
  4. Tower Heist, $13.2 million
  5. J. Edgar, $11.5 million
  6. A Very Harold & Kumar 3D Christmas, $5.9 million
  7. In Time, $4.2 million
  8. Paranormal Activity 3, $3.6 million
  9. Footloose, $2.7 million
  10. Real Steel, $2 million