While the actress visited the late night talk show dressed up as Captain Hook, she was surprised that the host wasn't also a fellow bad guy and instead looked like the fairest of them all, Snow White.
"I thought we we're going as Disney villains? That's the memo I got," she joked.
He responded: "No you're a villain, I'm a Disney princess," but not before he quipped that her velvet suit looked like it could belong to a very famous singer: "Did you make that yourself? You're Prince right?"
So which leading lady would Mindy have picked if she had a choice? "I would have loved to dress as a beautiful Disney Princess. Not to be racial but I would have been a great Princess Jasmine."
Unfortunately for her that costume was already taken by Kimmel's sidekick, Guillermo Rodriguez—yes, crop top and all!
But alas sexy Halloween costumes aren't exactly her style, Mindy went on to explain. In fact when she was little she was the same thing every year.
"I was always some version of a witch because my parents didn't want to spend money on a costume," She joked.
Good to see she finally got out of her costume rut!