Survivor is a great equalizer. Contestants are sent into the wild without food, shelter, soap, razors or toilet paper—arriving at camp with nothing more than the clothes on their backs.
And they certainly don't have makeup. Or do they?
We've become fixated on Survivor: Redemption Island's 21-year-old Castaway Andrea Boehlke (one of Boston Rob Mariano's fangirl minions on the Ometepe tribe), whose beautiful blue eyes seem to be enhanced by tinted lashes and a smudge of eyeliner.
In the past, Survivor contestants are allowed one "luxury" item, but this season it cannot be claimed until the Castaway arrives at Redemption Island. So how could Andrea be boosting those baby blues?
We asked an expert, Survivor alum (and superfab E! colleague) Brad Virata. He dishes this bit of scoop on former Cook Islands tribemate Becky Lee: "Her eyeliner literally lasted one month! She wore MAC smudgeproof. Maybe this girl is wearing the same thing?"
What do you think? Long-lasting makeup or outstanding DNA? Vote in our poll!