Did Katie Holmes Almost Star as Bisexual Drug Smuggling Piper in Orange Is the New Black?

Exclusive! Find out what the Netflix show's creator told us about the former Dawson's Creek actress

By Marc Malkin Aug 05, 2014 2:32 PMTags
E! Placeholder Image

Imagine Katie Holmes in prison.

Now, picture her getting down and very naughty with Laura Prepon.

Well, all of that could have actually happened!

Orange Is the New Black creator Jenji Kohan exclusively revealed to me last night that she considered the former Dawson's Creek teen queen for the starring role of Piper.

"I'm a big fan of hers," Kohan said at last night's OITNB event at the DGA in West Hollywood. "You know, I met with her."

Yes, Kohan talked to Holmes about playing Piper!

Michael Simon/startraksphoto.com

But as we know, the part eventually went to the now Emmy-nominated Taylor Schilling. "She had other things to do," Kohan said of Holmes. "And also in the beginning, no one knew what this was."

Funny enough, Holmes told me over the weekend while she was promoting her new movie The Giver that OITNB is one of her favorite shows.

Now let's say Holmes snags a guest spot on the Netflix series, whom should she play?

"I'm a big fan of Katie Holmes," Schilling said last night. "She could be friends with Lorna or like Lorna's Boston sister." (Lorna, played by Yael Stone, is in prison for fraud and stalking a man she went on one date with.)

Kate Mulgrew, who plays Red on the show, issued a warning to Ms. Holmes. "She better watch herself," Mulgrew said. "Pretty girls have to watch out in that prison."

Holmes joked that if she was ever on the show, she could finally show off her tattoos.

"No, I don't have any tattoos," she added with a laugh. "My child would kill me."

Watch: Did Katie Holmes Audition for "OITNB"?
Watch: Who's Next to Guest Star on "OITNB?"