Fox Searchlight Pictures

Hilary Swank: two-time Oscar winner...and thoughtless hag?

The actress's reputation is under attack today by none other than Gloria Allred, who is shocked—shocked!—that Swank didn't even touch base with one of the real-life inspirations for her upcoming film, Conviction.

So what exactly is Allred's latest publicity grab beef?

Seems Allred's panties are in a bunch because she believes the actress should have had the courtesy to ring up the family of Katharina Brow, whose grisly killing is at the center of Conviction.

"We don't think the burden should be on the murder victim's family members on how to get in touch with Hollywood upon reading the murder victim's going to be in a film," said Allred. "The film's producers, including Ms. Swank [who's listed as an executive producer] have never bothered to contact this family in the 10 years this film was made."

Allred made the comments at a press conference today, two days before the film hits theaters, flanked by Brow's son and daughter.

"This family has gone through a lot of pain and there's no reason to feel they should suffer more," said Allred. "They're not going to profit from this film. If we're talking about a murder we need to reach out to murder victims' families. As far as I'm concerned that should be the new principle in Hollywood."

"My mother was not just a name and was not and is not a person who should be used as a line in the script or just a way to make a profit in the entertainment industry," Melrose Brow added. "She was just a human being and a member of our family."

Allred says she plans on sending a letter to Swank via her agent ("because that's the only way we know how to contact her") on behalf of Brow's now grown-up children, Charlie and Melrose, demanding a face-to-face meeting.

"They need and deserve to receive answers to many questions they have," said Allred, adding that she wants the family to get a private screening to avoid having to re-live the incident in a theater surrounded by the popcorn-munching masses.

Specifically, the family wants to know: if their mom's murder be seen on screen; how will she be depicted (as "the loving mother and grandmother that she was?") and whether the filmmakers will earmark any of the profits to find the real killer.

While the public has yet to see Conviction, there have been several advanced screenings, so perhaps we here at E! can try and help clear up at least one mystery for the family.

Conviction opens in Brow's home and we see details of the crime scene, specifically shots of blood, but viewers don't see the actual slaying. At that point, the movie flashes forward two years to Kenneth Waters (Sam Rockwell), the man wrongly accused of the murder. Swank plays his sister, Betty Anne Waters, who eventually gets a law degree and helps prove her sibling's innocence. 

It's that story that's the focus of the movie and not the Brows' tribulations, though during the end credits, a title card notes that the real killer has yet to be found.

So far, reps for Swank and Fox Searchlight, the studio distributing Conviction, have decided not to take Allred's bait.

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share

We and our partners use cookies on this site to improve our service, perform analytics, personalize advertising, measure advertising performance, and remember website preferences. By using the site, you consent to these cookies. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our Cookie Policy.