Jenny makes an educated guess after seeing a big ol' diamond in Prince's clue package.
"I did see that diamond, so it made me think of a baseball diamond," Jenny says. "Or the engagement ring could be that infamous ring that be took back from J. Lo. I think it's Alex Rodriguez!"
Jenny isn't the only panelist with America's pastime on the brain, however. Prince's clue package includes a reference to the year 2006, which got some wheels turning.
"When I first started hearing the voice in the performance, I was thinking Enrique [Iglesias]," Robin Thicke says. "But I am on this athlete tip and now that we're in 2006, could it possibly be the Prince of New York, Derek Jeter?"
While J. Lo and Ben Affleck flaunt their love for the world to see, it doesn't appear that A-Rod is any worse for wear. The former Yankees star was spotted with fitness competitor Kathryne Padgett sitting courtside at the Minnesota Timberwolves play-in game against the LA Clippers on April 12.
This season, Philadelphia Eagles star Jordan Mailata has already been unmasked as Thingamabob. So, maybe another professional athlete has joined the competition!
Judge for yourself if A-Rod—or one of his Bronx Bomber teammates—might be Prince when The Masked Singer airs Wednesday at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.