Jennifer appeared on Watch What Happens Live on Thursday, Jan. 14, where Andy Cohen asked how she feels about some fans calling for her to join the cast of HBO Max's upcoming 10-episode series that will update viewers on the lives of Sarah Jessica Parker's Carrie, Cynthia Nixon's Miranda and Kristin Davis' Charlotte. Kim will not be returning to play Samantha in And Just Like That..., which begins production in the spring.
"I was a huge, and still am a huge, Sex and the City fan," the Legally Blonde actress replied. "It's one of those shows you can just watch the reruns and never get tired of them."
Jennifer, who actually played a role in a 2003 episode of the hit HBO comedy, continued by letting fans down gently.
"But I have to say I am such a Kim Cattrall fan, and I don't see anyone being able to replace her in that part," the 59-year-old American Pie standout explained. "It was just the perfect ... I don't think you can replace her."
This follows a fan having commented on Sarah's Instagram announcement about the revival on Sunday, Jan. 10 with a pitch for Jennifer to join the squad.
"No disrespect to Kim, but if she's not participating please please please recast Samantha with the awesome Jennifer Coolidge," the individual suggested. "I would line up and pay good money to see Jennifer as Samantha."
This led Sarah to coyly reply, "we have some new stories to tell. We are excited."
The star was even more explicit to a different commenter who asked about the fate of Samantha. "Samantha isnt part of this story," the Divorce alum wrote. "But she will always be part of us."
And Sarah doubled down on Jan. 13, telling a cameraperson that the show is "not looking to create a fourth character."
In other words, Jennifer doesn't have to worry about filling anyone's Manolo Blahniks.