While Juliette Porter was concerned when former cast member Alex Kompothecras' ex-girlfriend popped up in season two to rekindle their romance, Cara surprised everyone when she ended up dating Garrett Miller. But the two called it quits after she temporarily moved to New Jersey. They attempted to reconcile, but Cara memorably mad at her personal trainer boyfriend for not noticing her nose job in the season three premiere. Following allegations of cheating, Cara then quit the show on-camera and moved to New York.
After a rumored romance with JJ Mizell, she's back in Florida and is dating Michael Wheary, who is friends with Juliette's boyfriend Sam Logan. (Six degrees of Sarasota!) So, yes, we were a bit confused when she briefly appeared in the trailer for season four and seemed upset over Garrett's new relationship.