These Are Fall TV 2018's Best and Worst New Shows—According to You!

We asked, you voted: Find out what TV shows everyone is loving—and the ones you're hating

By TV Scoop Team Oct 30, 2018 12:30 PMTags
Fall TV splitABC, CW, NBC, FOX, CBS

A sure sign of the fall, aside from the changing leaves, is the rash of new TV shows premiering across the five major broadcast networks, NBC, CBS, Fox, ABC and The CW.

All of the new shows we're getting as part of the fall season have debuted—none have come and gone already, so that's good?—so, it's time you told us which are the best and worst new shows of the fall 2018 TV season. We already made our ranking, and now it's your turn. We asked you to vote in polls after each premiere week, weighing in on whether you loved or hated a new show. And we only counted new shows, not revivals like Murphy Brown and Last Man Standing, or quasi-spinoffs like The Conners.

Fall TV 2018 Winners and Losers

Below, see how you, dear readers, voted each show.

16. Rel (Fox)

ABOUT: Starring Lil Rel Howery and Sinbad, the series follows Rel as he gets his life back together after his marriage ends.


Love it: 20.4 percent
Hate it: 79.5 percent

15. Charmed (CW)

ABOUT: A remake of the fan-favorite WB series of the same name, the new Charmed follows a new group of witchy sisters navigating life and their new powers.


Love it: 41.2 percent
Hate it: 58.8 percent

14. Happy Together (CBS)

ABOUT: Inspired by real life events with executive producer Harry Styles, this CBS comedy sees a pop star (Felix Mallard) move in with normal folks, played by stars Damon Wayans Jr. and Amber Stevens West.


Love it: 47.4 percent
Hate it: 52.6 percent

13. All American (CW)

ABOUT: A family drama and fish out of water story about a young man who is recruited to play football in Beverly Hills.


Love it: 48.8 percent
Hate it: 51.2 percent

12. I Feel Bad (NBC)

ABOUT: Starring Sarayu Blue, this new NBC comedy follows a working mom trying to accept that not everything will be perfect.


Love it: 50.9 percent
Hate it: 49.1 percent

11. The Neighborhood (CBS)

ABOUT: Cedric the Entertainer, Max Greenfield, Tichina Arnold and Beth Behrs star in this comedy about a white family who moves into a traditionally black neighborhood.


Love it: 53.7 percent
Hate it: 46.3 percent

10. The Cool Kids (Fox)

ABOUT: Vicki Lawrence, David Alan Grier, Leslie Jordan and Martin Mull star as residents of a retirement community who aren't quite ready to grow up.


Love it: 55.3 percent
Hate it: 44.7 percent

9. Magnum P.I. (CBS)

ABOUT: Jay Hernandez stars in this remake of the classic Tom Selleck series about a military veteran who becomes a private eye.


Love it: 57.6 percent
Hate it: 42.4 percent

8. God Friended Me (CBS)

ABOUT: What would you do if you got a friend request from "God," followed by instructions and hints to help save others? That's the gist of this series starring Brandon Michael Hall.


Love it: 58.7 percent
Hate it: 41.3 percent

7. Legacies (CW)

ABOUT: A spinoff of The Originals, Legacies stars Matt Davis and takes place at a school for supernatural folks, like witches and vampires.


Love it: 59.3 percent
Hate it: 40.7 percent

6. FBI (CBS)

ABOUT: Law & Order guru Dick Wolf is behind this latest CBS procedural about law enforcement.


Love it: 67.8 percent
Hate it: 32.3 percent

5. Single Parents (ABC)

ABOUT: ABC's newest ensemble drama stars Taran Killam, Brad Garrett, Leighton Meester, Jake Choi and Kimrie Lewis as, well, single parents.


Love it: 69.1 percent
Hate it: 30.9 percent

4. A Million Little Things (ABC)

ABOUT: ABC's new weepy drama follows a group of friends who deal with the aftermath of a suicide.


Love it: 79.8 percent
Hate it: 20.2 percent

3. New Amsterdam (NBC)

ABOUT: Ryan Eggold stars in the latest medical drama to come to the small screen.


Love it: 85.8 percent
Hate it: 14.2 percent

2. Manifest (NBC)

ABOUT: What happens after a plane full of missing people returns after being missing for more than five years?


Love it: 87.9 percent
Hate it: 12.1 percent

1. The Rookie (ABC)

ABOUT: Nathan Fillion stars as a middle-aged rookie cop who joins the force after a life-changing experience.


Love it: 88.2 percent
Hate it: 11.8 percen

Surprised by the results? Tell us on Twitter.

Latest News