This one time...at band camp—yep, our favorite sexually active band geek (played by adorable Alyson Hannigan) has come a long way from her flute-playing days. After hooking up for a one-night stand with Jim on prom night in Pie, she helps him win over Nadia once and for all in Pie 2. But—oops—Michelle winds up falling for Jim, he eventually proposes and the American Wedding isn't far behind. Now the nerdy high school sweethearts have a baby—awww!
The resident party boy keeps up his wild ways throughout the American flicks, of course. After throwing the best prom afterparty known to man in Pie, Stifler manages to take over a beachhouse and, yep, have a party. That's followed by a ridiculously awesome bachelor party for his buddy Jim. As his character has grown (or not), however, Stifler's never gotten over catching his sexy cougar mom hook up with his classmate Paul Finch.
The angelic choir girl who's nervous about losing her virginity finally does the deed with Oz on prom night in the first flick, but their relationship isn't without its problems. Heather jets off for a summer abroad in Spain in Pie 2, but the couple miss the hell out of each other. After attempts at phone sex are interrupted, she decides to surprise Oz by flying back and showing up at the beachhouse. The two are totally in love, but will it last?
From doing it with a pie to an awkward encounter with hot foreign exchange student Nadia, Jim's antics steal the show in American Pie. He continues to pine over Nadia and enlists the help of prom date Michelle in order to help woo her. Turns out, he falls in love with Michelle and they get married. Maybe now he'll stop doing the dirty with desserts!
Sensitive jock Oz is a total gentleman: When he and Heather sleep together for the first time, he doesn't brag about it to his friends. Swoon! The young couple manage to stay together throughout college and even survive a long-distance relationship when she's abroad in Spain. Lucky for Oz, when the GF is out of town, he's got his boys, who always know how to cheer him up and get into trouble.
This hot blond bombshell dumps Kevin right after they have sex on prom night because she isn't confident their relationship can survive since they're both going off to different colleges. In Pie 2, during an awkward encounter with Kev at the beachhouse, it's clear Vicky has moved on when she is all over her new BF. Maybe after seeing him with another woman she'll want him back?
Friends forever—means a sex pact?! According to Pie's idea man Kevin, that is exactly what friends are for. After falling in love with his high school sweetheart, Vicky, Kev is brokenhearted to learn that after their first year in college in Pie 2 she has another boyfriend. He tries to win her back at the beachhouse, but is unsuccessful. Kev moves on, marries someone else and becomes an architect, but how happy is he? We're hoping for a Kev and Vicky hookup!
Vicky's quirky BFF Jessica always knows what to say, especially when it comes to sex. She loves to dish it out, but where is her beau? At the Reunion perhaps...
Forever known as the dude who lost his virginity to Stifler's mom, Finch is a Pie legend. After his cougar encounter, Finch is left wanting more and sneaks off with Stifler's mom at the end of American Pie 2. Unsurprisingly, he's competing with Stifler for the older women in American Wedding, but for whatever reason he only fits with Stifler's mom—let's hope the Reunion finds its way back to our favorite MILF and dork couple.
We will be eternally grateful to John, who coined the term MILF in the original American Pie flick. Known around the American crew as MILF No. 2, his one-liners never cease to impress us. As he reunites with MILF No. 1, crazy, wild times are bound to follow.