Amy Sussman/E! Entertainment/NBCU Photo Bank
The Bachelor thought he found a soulmate in Cassie during his season, but in the end the two decided they are better off as friends.
Their breakup initially appeared cordial, but after four months, Cassie obtained a restraining order against the former footballer, claiming he was stalking her. Cassie later asked the court to dismiss the restraining order, with Colton explaining in a statement that they came to a "private agreement."