During a round of, "Who Dunnit?" contestants had to guess whether Sarah Hyland or Wells Adams had once "urinated on a subway track," as the latter described it. Joel McHale, despite saying that the "obvious choice would be Wells because, as you can see, he's filthy," guessed Sarah, while everyone else opted for Wells.
However, Sarah was indeed the guilty one! "It was 4 a.m. in Brooklyn. The L train," she recalled. "I was a little bit inebriated—or a lot. And I really had to pee. But you know, the L train never comes!"