Hoo boy. Where to begin with this one?
We were genuinely happy for these two when it appeared they had found love in Paradise, especially because Jordan seemed like one of those contestants who would remain a character in this world for a long time. But they looked so happy as they left the show engaged, and then on the day that proposal episode aired, s--t hit the fan. Reality Steve posted screenshots of an alleged text exchange between Jenna and another guy, and it seemed to imply that Jenna had been cheating on Jordan and was just using him for publicity for her business.
Jordan immediately broke things off (handling the whole thing pretty well, actually) and Jenna started threatening legal action and even revealed "forensic investigation" results proving it was all fake. The damage was done no matter what.
We'll always remember them for so many reasons, but we'll truly never be able to forget Jordan throwing that giant stuffed animal into the ocean in a rage.