Sure we swooned over Angel on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but ain't no shame in a Spike crush, too. Do you remember these cuties from the 1990's?
Who better to break curfew with than the leader of the Midnight Society? Gary from Are You Afraid of the Dark? would protect you from any scary story-induced nightmares.
The Brink! star was always racing through our dreams.
Our only worry about dating the Nickelodeon star is that his Cousin Skeeter may insist on tagging along as a third wheel.
The Free Willy star was an animal lover, obviously. How sweet is that?! Our song would be Michael Jackson's "Will You Be There."
This Terminator 2 star had major bad boy vibes happening.
We used to write "Mrs. Red Power Ranger" in all of our Lisa Frank notebooks.
Christian Oliver was the older guy crush Luca in the big screen adaptation of The Baby-Sitters Club. Who wouldn't fall head over heels over those dimples?!
One of our Disney Channel Original Movie favorites, Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century showed Zenon getting into a long-distance situation with Earth cutie, Greg. He's not in the subsequent Zenon sequels, so maybe it's safe to assume Greg's available now?
The Sandlot star was a total jock, and we loved it.
The girls on Sister, Sister were always telling him to "go home, Roger," but Marques Houston is welcome to hang out with us anytime.
He's the main reason we watched Jawbreaker on repeat.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer's Spike had platinum spiked tips and a bad attitude, and we still couldn't get enough of this bad boy.
A '90s hunk playing a '70s hottie, Dazed and Confused's Jason London totally had us smitten with that retro look and tousled hair.
Remember Elizabeth's BF Todd Wilkins from Sweet Valley High? We had major feelings for this hot athlete.
The real magic of Sabrina, the Teenage Witch was Harvey's smile.
Hot. Teacher. Alert. We've never been so jealous of Drew Barrymore as when she ends up with this Never Been Kissed hunk. Damn.
This 7th Heaven star was the underrated cutie of the show. Sure, older bro Eric Camden (Barry Watson) was swoonworthy, too, but Simon grew into a blond dreamboat.
Remember that time Tommy Page serenaded Stephanie on Full House? We've been in love ever since.
Bring It On. Not the movie, just more Jesse Bradford, please.
Look at the Empire Records' star's smile. Enough said. This was our sexual awakening right here.
David Lascher is a major hottie, but it was his Hey Dude days that spoke to us the most. He had that hot upperclassman vibe as a member of the senior staff at the Bar None Ranch.
Mike Damus was the guardian angel from the short-lived ABC TGIF show Teen Angel. You know, the one who died from eating a six-month-old hamburger from under his BFF's bed? We can't get over that perfect '90s hair.