Shawn Hunter from Boy Meets World captured our hearts as Cory Matthews' bad boy BFF. Sure he was a bit of a ladies' man, but Shawn was such a sweetheart we couldn't help but crush on him.
The That '70s Show star was a super-hot exchange student. Jackie resisted his flirting through much of the show, but he could charm us with that accent any day.
Shane West in A Walk to Remember emotionally devastated us with the level of romance he had for Mandy Moore's character. Ugh... we he built her a telescope?! We cannot handle it.
We first fell in love with Will Smith on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, and we've been crushing ever since.
My So-Called Life? More like our so-called crush. Leto's Jordan Catalano on the short-lived mid-'90s series won us over with his adorable long locks and songwriting skills. We wanted to tutor him in the ways of literacy and love.
The sexy singer's been fiiiiiine since he hit the scene in the '90s, showing off his abs, dance moves, and amazing voice. "U Got It Bad" gives us life.
The Titanic star is still single, ladies!
Kelso was so stupid (and stupid-hot) on That '70s Show. We'll admit we were pretty jealous of Jackie, both on the show and now of Mila Kunis in real life.
Look at those guns! As A.C. Slater on Saved by the Bell, Lopez portrayed the star school athlete who people either want to be (or be with) in school. Whenever he would call Jessie "mama" we would get weak in the knees.
The star was so young (and so cute) on his 3rd Rock from the Sun days way back when. He has since grown up and ditched the long locks, but we still have a place in our hearts for the swoon-worthy JGL.
As big bro Eric Matthews on Boy Meets World, Will Friedle may have been a slacker, goofy type... but that cute smileeeeee.
The Lawrence family has been good to us! Matthew, plus his brothers Joey and Andrew, are a trio of cuties!
Freaks and Geeks era James Franco may be our favorite James Franco.
Ryan Phillippe in Cruel Intentions was everyone's sexual awakening, right?
Sean Patrick Thomas is all kinds of fine. Between Cruel Intentions and Save the Last Dance, Thomas has been making us swoon for years.
Is it something about guys with three names? We still have dreams about Saved by the Bell's Mark-Paul Gosselaar.
We can all agree: Rufio from Hook was a major hottie.
If someone ever says to you... "Chad Michael Murray?" The answer is always "yes." Regardless of the question attached.
Paul Rudd has looked basically the same since Clueless. He was handsome then, and he's still hella handsome now.
Have mercy!
The star will always be Dawson's Creek's Pacey to us.
Seriously, how adorable was the Home Improvement cutie?
He may have been an "Angel" on Buffy, but Boreanaz made us think naughty thoughts.
When Devon Sawa whispered "can I keep you?" in Casper... we can't...