Knocked out in round one by Neil Patrick Harris
Knocked out in round one by Jay Ryan
Knocked out by Misha Collins in the Elite 8
Knocked out in round two by Jensen Ackles
Knocked out in round one by Alexander Skarsgard
Knocked out in round two by Toby Regbo
Knocked out in the final four by Jay Ryan
Knocked out in round one by Jim Parsons
Knocked out in round two by Matt Bomer
Knocked out in the Sweet 16 by Benedict Cumberbatch
Knocked out in round one by Michael Ealy
Knocked out in round one by Josh Dallas
Knocked out in round one by Matt Bomer
Knocked out in round one by Ian Harding
Knocked out in the Sweet 16 by Tony Goldwyn
Knocked out in round one by Paul Wesley
PHOTOS: Renewed, canceled or on the bubble? Find out where your favorite shows stand