The 21-year-old pop star and the 19-year-old model and daughter of actor Stephen Baldwin have sparked romance rumors several times over the past year. In February, Hailey told E! News she and Bieber were just friends.
On New Year's Eve, Hailey posted on her Instagram page a black and white photo of her and Bieber looking particularly cozy. They are pictured at what appears to be a party on a wooden landing. Hailey is standing behind Bieber with her arms wrapped around his neck and her face touching it, possibly kissing it, while the singer stared straight into the lens.