Watch James Marsden Play the Gay Edition of Shag, Marry, Kill—Plus, What Does the Single Actor Look for in a Woman? Find Out

Caller asks the actor to choose between Andy Cohen, Anderson Cooper and Neil Patrick Harris while on Watch What Happens Live

By Bruna Nessif Oct 16, 2014 10:14 PMTags
James MarsdenCharles Sykes/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

We love when stars play along.

Hollywood hunk James Marsden appeared on Bravo's Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen alongside Minnie Driver last night, and while answering caller questions during the after show, the blue-eyed cutie ended up being put on the spot with a little game many of us are familiar with...but with a twist.

One fan asked the Best of Me star, "James, if you were gay, who would you shag? Who would you kill? Who would you marry?" and gave Marsden his three choices: Andy Cohen, Anderson Cooper and Neil Patrick Harris (yeah, that wasn't awkward for Andy at all).

"I would...he's a wonderful human being, but I would kill Neil Patrick Harris," Marsden began to say. "He's a talented, wonderful guy, but I have to choose someone. And I think that I would marry Anderson, which means I'd shag you," the actor said to Andy.

Earlier in the show, Marsden revealed to another caller that he is single and was later asked what qualities he looks for in a woman (ladies, are you ready to write this down?).

Joking around with the fan on the phone, James asked her to repeat her name and then answered, "I love a good name in a woman. I love my name in—no. How do I answer? I'm going to start lying just to make stuff up?" Cohen then asked what his type is and what physical attributes he's attracted to. "My type? I don't have a type. Just stunning, I guess," Marsden replied. "Yeah, I think stunning-ish."

Stunning-ish and a good name? Done and done.