Andi Dorfman Remains Coy About Falling in Love on The Bachelorette, but Totally Falls for Terrence Jenkins' Amazing Pickup Line

Watch E! News' smoothest cohost convince Andi to choose him during a round of the E! Dating Game

By Natalie Finn May 21, 2014 2:04 AMTags

Some guys just have it.

The Bachelorette's Andi Dorfman was contractually obligated to exercise her right to remain silent while being grilled about the current state of her love life by E! News' Giuliana Rancic and Ali Fedotowsky, who tried their darndest to get just a sliver of information out of this season's lady of the hour, who was seen meeting all of her suitors on last night's premiere.

But while Andi wouldn't admit whether her smile was "the smile of a woman in love," as Ali insisted it must be, the Atlanta-based prosecutor did genuinely perk up after a round of the E! Dating Game, featuring Jason Kennedy, Terrence Jenkins and Jesse Giddings as the expert pitchers of woo.

Asked about their idea for a perfect first date, Jason suggested a visit with Andi's parents and Terrence went for a trip to his hometown, the two obviously playing off of the Bachelor and Bachelorette's infamous hometown visits.

Instead of comparing his personality to that of a car, as he was asked, Jesse insisted that he was more of a motorcycle. "A Triumph motorcycle based on the early 1950s," he gushed about himself. "It's rustic, it's vintage, it's clssic and it's a little badass."

But it was the pickup lines that sealed the deal for Andi.

E! Entertainment

Jason went the lusty yet wholesome route: "Is your dad a baker, 'cause you got a pretty nice pair of buns."

Jesse kicked it up a notch with, "Do you work at the post office, 'cause I saw you checking out my package."

But it was Terrence, and his reason as to why Andi should "go black," that is going to win over every E! News viewer tonight.

Watch the clip to see how Terrence brings the Dating Game home, and see him and Giuliana do their thing every weeknight on E! News at 7 p.m. and 11:30 p.m.