Justin Theroux, Jennifer Aniston

Jason Thomas/FilmMagic

About Jennifer Aniston's gaudy new engagement ring: It's just too big, right?
—Allison J., via Twitter

You speak of a stone so large that it has its own gravity well. How Justin Theroux managed to bring it crashing down from space and through Earth's cruel atmosphere is a mystery at this hour, but I can tell you what experts are saying about the bauble.

Yes, the ring looks a little...weird, even on Aniston's ever-sexy hand.

But it may not be a function of the ring's size, with a center stone estimated at about 8 carats.

Instead, says designer David Nygaard of David Nygaard Fine Jewelers, the problem, if you see one, is likely with the setting.

"The challenge with a large diamond, or any gem, is the design," he says. "Yes, sure, some stones are pendant stones, but I've never found that a stone on its own can be too big for a hand."

In fact, Nygaard says, he's worked with center stones "upwards of 15 carats."

So why might this ring and setting, said to have a total of 12 to 18 carats, look odd to so many? Nygaard has some theories.

"As it is, it may just be unbalanced, a little bulky looking, not pleasing aesthetically," he says. "I would have made the band, or the shank, of the ring a little larger, or maybe a split shank.

"After all, today, with so many custom design options available and computer-assisted design, you can have your ring exactly as you want it."

If Aniston herself has a problem with that ring, she sure doesn't seem to be showing it.

Bling in orbit: These are some seriously big celebrity rings!


  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share

We and our partners use cookies on this site to improve our service, perform analytics, personalize advertising, measure advertising performance, and remember website preferences. By using the site, you consent to these cookies. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our Cookie Policy.