Butter Premiere Face-Off: Olivia Wilde vs. Jennifer Garner vs. Ashley Greene in NYC

Three looks for one tasty movie celebration, but who will get your vote for best dressed?

By Leslie Gornstein Sep 28, 2012 5:06 PMTags
Ashley Greene, Jennifer Garner, Olivia WildeDimitrios Kambouris/WireImage; Jackson Lee/Splash

How do you dress to celebrate a movie about butter carving? Smooth! Slick! Maybe a little greasy!

Well, OK, neither Jennifer Garner nor Ashley Green nor Olivia Wilde appeared particularly well coated in fat as they walked the carpet for Butter in New York. In fact, quite the opposite, because these are celebrities—they lose their Hollywood citizenship if they report for duty weighing more than a 12-year-old gymnast.

But their makeup did seem to be spread a bit thin. We'll stop now.

First there was Garner, who also produced the movie, wearing a strapless Gucci maxi and a cuff that, together, are about as exciting as a stick of unsalted margarine.

Greene, usually more flavorful in the sartorial department, wore a rather daytime-y blush number.

While Olivia updated an otherwise tired Queen Anne neckline with some shoulder pads she found on the set of TRON. We liked this McQueen—it was salty.

OK, really, we promise—we'll stop now.


The Fashion Police September 28 Poll

Which Butter premiere look makes the best fashion spread?
Ashley Greene
Jennifer Garner
Olivia Wilde