Wednesday DVR Deathmatch: Modern Family vs. Supernatural vs. X Factor

Read our rundowns of hump-day shows, divided by time slots, and tells us your choices

By Jenna Mullins Sep 05, 2012 10:45 PMTags
E! Placeholder Image

Can the other networks go up against ABC's legendary Wednesday-night comedy lineup (it includes Modern Family and The Middle, for starters) and win in a DVR match to the death? Well, Fox is pulling out the big guns to try and do just that. And by big guns, we mean Britney "Queen of Pop" Spears.

In today's DVR Deathmatch, Wednesday nights are jam-packed with CBS procedurals, a CW favorite, and a pretty much brand-new NBC lineup. Check out the breakdown of time slots below, and then pick the one show in each time period that you'll be watching live. Does Britney get your pick? Or are you loyal to your CBS standbys? We're dying to know, so have at it!

Poll

DVR Deathmatch: Wednesday (8 p.m.)

8 p.m.
Survivor (CBS)
13.1%
Animal Practice (NBC)
5.9%
The Middle (ABC)
17.1%
Arrow (CW)
38.5%
The X Factor
25.4%
Poll

DVR Deathmatch: Wednesday (8:30 p.m.)

8:30 p.m.
Survivor (CBS)
13.5%
Guys With Kids (NBC)
9.2%
The Neighbors (ABC)
6.1%
Arrow (CW)
43.6%
The X Factor (Fox)
27.6%
Poll

DVR Deathmatch: Wednesday (9 p.m.)

9 p.m.
Criminal Minds (CBS)
11.1%
Law & Order: SVU (NBC)
2.7%
Modern Family (ABC)
33.6%
Supernatural (CW)
42.1%
The X Factor (Fox)
10.4%
Poll

DVR Deathmatch: Wednesday (9:30 p.m.)

9:30 p.m.
Criminal Minds (CBS)
13.8%
Law & Order: SVU (NBC)
5.8%
Suburgatory (ABC)
18.2%
Supernatural (CW)
45.7%
The X Factor (Fox)
16.5%
Poll

DVR Deathmatch: Wednesday (10 p.m.)

10 p.m.
CSI (CBS)
30.6%
Chicago Fire (NBC)
19.2%
Nashville (ABC)
50.2%