Hugh Jackman, Alexander Sarsgard, Ryan Reynolds, Robert Pattinson, Johnny Depp

Jun Sato/Getty Images; Jason LaVeris/Getty Images; Todd Williamson/Getty Images; Charley Gallay/Getty Images; Jon Furniss/Getty Images

Apparently, you're not really feelin' Johnny Depp.

Based on your numerous comments and clicks on our poll this morning, many of you agree with People's pick for Sexiest Man Alive, but a majority of you would have gone in a different direction.

Well, we hear you loud and clear...and you're not alone.

"I'm a bit surprised," a taken-aback America's Next Top Model judge "Miss J" Alexander told us at the VH1 Save the Music Big Shopping event at the W Hotel Times Square this afternoon.

We read what you had to say about this hot-button issue and tallied your first choices (yeah, we're that scientific from time to time). We're not going to lie—you surprised us.

Your hottest hottie, by a landslide, is...

True Blood's Alexander Skarsgård!


Get him and more in Your Hottest Hotties gallery of suggested studs, in descending order of popularity based on your—yes, your!—comments.

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share