At least, according to Elmo and Grover, that is.
The actor recently stopped by Sesame Street to learn all about the letter "G," you know, as in games. Unfortunately for Brett, he got a little tied up when they tried to play jump rope together.
However, he proved to be a natural when the Muppets decided to spring a surprise game of hide and seek on him.
"You look like a friend of mine," Brett noted when finding Elmo disguised as Jason Sudeikis' titular Ted at one point. Other moments that had us believing: There were, of course, biscuits served and AFC Richmond merch.
Of course, this wasn't Brett's first time in the neighborhood. Last year, he met Oscar the Grouch. Though their reunion didn't exactly sweep the clouds away. When Brett challenged the trashcan-loving Muppet to a game of checkers, he was promptly told to scram.
Though, this is Sesame Street, so there were still some sunny rays. Like at the end when Grover eventually told Brett, "You are good at games."
Brett will be returning to the world of Jim Henson puppetry as a guest star on season two of Fraggle Rock: Back to the Rock on Apple TV+.
Meanwhile, season three of Ted Lasso is expected to air in 2023 on Apple TV+ while Sesame Street airs on PBS and HBO Max.