On the Wednesday, Nov. 20 episode of The Nick Cannon Show, Nick and Andy played a game of Plead the Fifth, which is known to elicit some crazy responses.
Nick went first and revealed that he does not slide into women's DMs as the Bravo star suspected. For Andy's first question, he plead the fifth instead of revealing the "three worst guests" on Watch What Happens Live.
Later in the game, Andy quizzed Nick on who his favorite baby mama is. (For a refresher, Nick has seven children total with four different partners: Mariah Carey, Alyssa Scott, Abby De La Rosa and Brittany Bell.)
While the audience shouted at Nick to plead the fifth, the star defiantly said, "I got this. I ain't scared of you, Andy."
"My favorite baby mama is," Nick said, pausing for dramatic effect, "the next one!"
Suffice to say the crowd and Andy were shocked by his response.
Nick went on to say that one of his "past baby mamas could still be my next one," adding, "That's all I'm saying!"
The 41-year-old previously said that he's decided to be celibate after welcoming four kids in a span of a year.
"I told you, man, I'm celibate right now," the father of seven said in an Oct. 4 interview on Revolt's Drink Champs. "I'm going to see if I could make it to 2022."
As he put it, "I have enough children, enough frolicking, I'm good right now."
But, a month later, Nick seemingly offered to end his vow of celibacy for Saweetie, who tweeted, "I want some babies."
In response, the Masked Singer host quote-tweeted her with a thinking face, ninja, rolling on the floor laughing and man raising one hand emojis.
So, if she's interested, Saweetie could be Nick's next favorite baby mama!