Ashley Tisdale Candidly Weighs In on the Difference Between HSM's Sharpay and Gabriella

Spoken like a true Sharpay, Ashley Tisdale reflected on the what set her High School Musical character apart from Vanessa Hudgens' Gabriella and why kids ended up liking the villain.

By Samantha Schnurr Aug 19, 2021 6:02 PMTags
Watch: Ashley Tisdale Not Interested in "High School Musical" Reboot

Sharpay was focused on bopping to the top, but Gabriella? Eh, not so much, according to Ashley Tisdale

Famous for bringing East High School's Drama Club President Sharpay Evans to life, the High School Musical alum recently weighed in on the stark difference she saw between her character and Vanessa Hudgens' Gabriella Montez. 

"It's funny because a lot of young kids did react. You know, they loved Sharpay," she recalled in a Good Morning America interview. "And I remember Disney being like, 'Why do the kids love this character? She's supposed to be the villain.'" 

While she was the antagonist, youngsters recognized a quality they admired. "They had shown it to a couple of kids," Tisdale explained. "An 8-year-old was like, 'I love it because she knows what she wants and she goes and gets it,' and I was like, 'She totally understands! This 8-year-old understands this.'"

High School Musical Cast: Where Are They Now?

Since the first High School Musical movie came two years after Mean Girls, Tisdale drew inspiration from unapologetic queen bee Regina George, made famous by Rachel McAdams. "You love these characters," Tisdale said, "and you want to see more of them on-screen, so I wanted Sharpay to be the same way."
In Tisdale's case, Sharpay wanted to rule the stage. "The entire time she was just business-driven. She just wanted to work and do the musicals," she said of her character. "Gabriella was off with Troy just wanting to chase a relationship." 

Frenemies to the end, it seems. Now, what time is it? Time for some secrets from behind the scenes of the hit Disney franchise. All you have to do is keep scrolling. 

1. The title High School Musical was initially just a placeholder as Disney and the filmmakers had not yet decided on a name. 

2. Hunter Parrish and Sterling Knight both auditioned for the role of Troy Bolton, losing out, of course, to Zac Efrom. However, they would go on to star alongside him in 17 Again, playing his high school nemesis/daughter's loser boyfriend and his son, respectively. 

3. Corbin Bleu, meanwhile, first auditioned for Ryan Evans, telling Buzzfeed, "At the time, I didn't know about the role of Chad Danforth." Once he landed the role, Corbin actually became the person to come up with all of the catchphrases on Chad's signature graphic t-shirts. "They're in a box in my garage," he revealed of Chad's collection.

4. Before going on to land the roles of Sharpay and Taylor, both Ashley Tisdale and Monique Coleman auditioned for Gabriella. "I just knew that I was terrible," Monique said of her Gabriella audition. "I didn't really feel equipped to sing and dance."

5. Lucas Grabeel, meanwhile, first read for the part of Troy, but knew right away he wasn't landing the role: "I went in right after Drew Seeley, who ended up singing for Troy in the movie," he told Buzzfeed. "I obviously heard him because it was in a trailer, so it was really thin walls and I was like, oh shit. I'm totally not gonna get this because that guy's incredible."

6. Oh yeah, in case you didn't know: Drew actually provided the singing voice for Troy in the first HSM movie, which was blended with Zac's as the part was written for a tenor and Zac is a baritone. Drew would go on to fill in for Zac on the High School Musical tour when scheduling conflicts got in the way, but for the follow-up movies, it was all Zac on Troy's tracks.

"That was a very huge point for me. I had to put my foot down and fight to get my voice on these tracks," Zac told the Orlando Sentinel. "In the first movie, after everything was recorded, my voice was not on them. I was not really given an explanation. It just kind of happened that way. Unfortunately, it put me in an awkward position."

7. According to Rolling Stone's iconic cover story on Zac (aka "The New American Heartthrob"), one in three teenage girls in America actually had a poster of him on their wall (though they cited a random web site for this factoid). 

8. The sibling rivalry was just as real off-screen as it was on-screen for Ashley and least at first. "We were not close. We were not good friends...we hated each other," Ashley admitted during a video she recorded with Lucas for her YouTube channel. Lucas added that the pair "didn't get off on the best foot" when they started filming the first movie, but eventually became close friends. How fabulous!

9. In an interview with Buzzfeed, Lucas revealed he pushed for Ryan's sexuality to be explored early on. "After reading the script, the first thing I said to [Kenny Ortega] was, 'OK, Kenny, Ryan's gay, right? I know it's Disney Channel so I'm not really gonna be gay, but I mean, yeah, right?' And he's like, 'Well, think of it this way: You have the opportunity to play a character who's young, he's into theater, he's an artist and let's go at it from that point of view,'" Lucas explained. "He talked to me about his own life and he was like, 'I see a lot of myself in Ryan. Yeah, I knew I was gay in high school, but I didn't tell anybody.' It was about making it real."

10. Ryan's iconic jazz squares were all Lucas' creation, along with Ryan and Sharpay's vocal warm-up exercises. "It's making fun of, but also an homage to two different choreographers I had when I was a kid who would put jazz squares in every single number," Lucas revealed. "They never said, 'Everybody loves a good jazz square,' but it just fit, so I wanted to make it a thing that Ryan wanted to put a jazz square in every number."

11. On the set, Kenny kept a yawn jar, which anyone who yawned had to contribute to. "Every year for, like, five years, on Christmas he would donate to a charity in our names," Monique said, noting the money went to the Make-A-Wish Foundation of Utah. 

12. After filming on the first movie finished, Monique returned home to discover an eviction notice on her door and was struggling to pay her bills, as was Lucas who had trouble booking another job after the HSM

13. After the record-breaking success of the first film, Disney gave fans the chance to weigh in on decisions on the highly anticipated sequel, including slogans that would appear on Chad's t-shirts, the type of sandwiches Troy and Gabriella would eat on their date and the (very brief) appearance by Hannah Montana star Miley Cyrus. 

14. Like her on-screen character Ms. Darbus, the drama teacher at East High, Alyson Reed helped mentor the kids off-screen too. In fact, she even went on to become Monique's acting teacher. "She was the person I felt the most comfortable with," Monique told Buzzfeed. "I really credit her with helping me get my confidence back."

15. The third film in the franchise was initially intended to be a Halloween-themed feature called Haunted High School Musical, but the concept was ultimately (and fortunately) dropped, with Zac telling MTV at the time, "Yeah, I don't think the haunted thing lasted very long." The third and final film, the only HSM movie to hit theaters, was then called High School Musical: Senior Year

16. Selena Gomez was almost cast in HSM 3 as Tiara Gold, Sharpay's new rival. But, the Disney darling decided to turn down the role "because I didn't want to do it," she told the New York Daily News at the time. "I plan to take other roles in acting that are challenging for me. After Disney, I want to be taken seriously as an actress for many years." Ali Lohan also reportedly went out for the role that ultimately went to Jemma McKenzie-Brown.

17. Chad's dad appears for the first time in the third installment, and Mr. Danforth is played by Corbin's real-life father, David Reivers. (They also played father and son in Jump In! and Free Style.)

18. Ashley revealed to Buzzfeed that she took home almost all of Sharpay's wardrobe from the first movie, admitting, "Did I think I was going to wear them on the red carpet? Probably, at the time." And when Disney tried to eventually get the items back, Ashley pulled a Sharpay and said she'd rather stick toothpicks into her eyes. "I was like, "No, this is mine.' So they don't have any of the clothes from the first movie. I do."

19. When the first movie came out, fans obsessed over which cast members might be dating, with many thinking Zac and Ashley were an item. "I remember people thinking that Zac Efron and I dated, because we were on a lot of magazine covers together, because we were promoting the first movie," Ashley recalled. "So, we just thought that was really funny, because he was obviously dating someone else, and he's my best friend."

20. Ah yes, Zanessa. HSM fans had a near meltdown when it was revealed Zac and Vanessa were a couple IRL. They would go on to date for four years, becoming one of young Hollywood's most beloved couples before their split in 2010. "It started off really organically," Vanessa recalled on THR's Awards Chatter podcast. "I could not have been more grateful to have that relationship at the time."

21. While they kept it professional on the set of the movies, they once fought during HSM 3. "I remember one time we did have a fight and it was while we were at rehearsals," she remembered, "and I remember Kenny Ortega coming around the corner with the most concerned look on his face like, 'Oh no, is our movie going to fall apart right?'"

22. In 2016, Disney Channel announced a casting call for High School Musical 4, looking for a new generation of east High Wildcats to continue the franchise. Jeffrey Hornaday, who directed Disney Channel hits Teen Beach Movie and Teen Beach 2, was attached to direct and choreograph the new movie, which ultimately never ended up coming to fruition. 

23. The High School Musical soundtrack was the top-selling album of 2006, per Billboard, with 3.7 million copies sold, and was the first-ever TV Movie soundtrack to hit No. 1 on the sales chart. 

24. High School Musical 2 is still one of the highest rated Disney Channel Original Movie of all-time, drawing a whopping 17.2 million viewers. "This was our Super Bowl," Disney Channel president Gary Marsh said at the time. "I think we have officially crossed the line from High School Musical the movie to High School Musical the mania."

25. With a budget of just $11 million, High School Musical 3: Senior Year grossed over $250 million worldwide in 2008, debuting at No. 1 at the box office in its first week.