This led some media outlets and fan blogs to speculate about whether the Bachelor in Paradise alums might be reconciling, given that their children, Isabella, 3, and Charlie, 17 months, didn't join them for the meal. Evan also has three older children from a previous relationship who were not present.
But not so fast. E! News has learned that while Carly, 35, and Evan, 38, did break bread together in honor of the special day, they're not rekindling their romantic feelings. Instead, they're still focused on cultivating a supportive friendship to maintain stability for the kids.
"Carly and Evan wish to have a civil relationship with each other for the best interest of their children," Carly's team tells E! News in a statement. "Carly and Evan shared Mother's Day together to catch each other up on their lives, and discussed co-parenting and the children's summer schedules."
Neither star has shared anything to social media from their time together over the weekend. However, Carly posted a precious photo to Instagram on Monday, May 10 that showed herself dressed up in a superhero-style mask and cape, with Isabella and Charlie both wearing similar capes as well.
"Happy Belated Mother's Day from my crew! Hope all you mamas got allllll the love," the proud mom captioned it.
Sure enough, with great power comes great responsibility—to borrow a mantra from another masked do-gooder—and Carly and Evan clearly take that seriously.