The (Actual) Most Dramatic Season Finales in Bachelor History

Take a trip down memory lane with these emotional reality show moments

By Jess Cohen Mar 12, 2019 7:29 PMTags
Watch: Colton Underwood Explains His "Bachelor" Fence Jump

We're just hours away from the conclusion of Colton Underwood's season of The Bachelor.

On Monday, viewers saw the first half of the two-part finale, with Colton breaking up with Tayshia Adams and Hannah Godwin. In hopes of reuniting with Cassie Randolph, who put an end to their relationship in a tearful goodbye last week, Colton told both Tayshia and Hannah that he "can't love two people." After watching the breakups, Colton reunited with both women on the live finale, attempting to offer them closure.

The episode ended with Colton on a mission to win Cassie back, knocking on a hotel room door. Tonight, we'll see if Colton and Cassie end up together. But before the episode airs, we're looking back on more of the most dramatic season finales in Bachelor Nation history!

Dramatic Bachelor Finales

Let's take a trip down drama lane with these buzz-worthy finales from The Bachelor, The Bachelorette and Bachelor in Paradise!

Jason Mesnick, The Bachelor, Season 13

At the end of season 13, Jason told Molly Malaney that he was "in love with somebody else." He later got engaged to Melissa Rycroft, but then decided that he changed his mind, ending the relationship with Melissa and getting back together with Molly.

Juan Pablo, The Bachelor, Season 18

Though Juan Pablo chose Nikki Ferrell at the end of season 18, he didn't get down on one knee. Then on the After the Final Rose show, Nikki shared that Juan Pablo still hadn't said "I love you" to her.

Arie Luyendyk Jr., The Bachelor, Season 22

After proposing to Becca Kufrin on season 22 of The Bachelor, Arie Luyendyk Jr. decided that he had "a change of heart." Arie shared with Becca that he wanted to reconcile with runner-up Lauren Burnham, to which she replied, "Are you f--king kidding me?"

The duo's relationship came to an end on the emotional season finale, with Arie and Lauren later getting back together.

Colton Underwood, The Bachelor, Season 23

On the first half of the season 23 finale, we saw Colton end his relationships with both Tayshia and Hannah. The tearful goodbyes were followed by live reunions between Colton and Tayshia and Colton and Hannah, during which the women attempted to get answers about their respective relationships. The episode ended with Colton declaring to win Cassie back.

Rachel Lindsay, The Bachelorette, Season 13

On the season 13 finale of The Bachelorette, Rachel Lindsay and Peter Kraus had a tearful discussion about getting engaged. 

"I don't know what I want to do tomorrow, because that is one day that means the rest of my life," Peter told Rachel.

After ending her relationship with Peter, Rachel went on to get engaged to Bryan Abasolo on the finale.

Carly Waddell & Kirk DeWindt, Bachelor in Paradise, Season 2

During the Bachelor in Paradise season two finale, Kirk shocked Carly (and everyone!) when he decided to end their relationship. The tearful goodbye led to Carly immediately packing her bags and leaving paradise.

Part two of The Bachelor's season 23 finale airs tonight at 8 p.m. on ABC.