Christina Applegate (Samantha Who), Lee Pace (Pushing Daisies), Blake Lively (Gossip Girl)

ABC / Craig Sjodin, ABC / Justin Stephens, Frank Ocknfels / The CW Network, LLC

Forget the Nielsens. Forget the media. Forget the hype. If you want to know the real story on fall TV's biggest winners and losers, look no further than you!

Thousands of you TV fans voted in our first annual Save It or Sink It Campaign, which asked for feedback on which new series you're loving—or loathing. And the results are in!

As you can see below, Pushing Daisies, Samantha Who? and Gossip Girl are instant favorites among fans, while Cavemen and Viva Laughlin have fallen flat. (The latter is no surprise, given that it was canceled after only one episode.) 

Some of you have been asking which new series are safe and which are not, so we've also listed the status of each show (where known).

Are you still fans of the shows you wanted to Save? Are you okay with those that are Sinking? Check out the results below, and if you see any struggling shows you want to save, feel free to try and sway the masses in our Comments section!


80% (voted to save it)—Pushing Daisies (ABC), full season ordered

68%—Samantha Who? (ABC), additional episodes ordered

64%—Gossip Girl (CW), full season ordered

63%—Chuck (NBC), additional episodes ordered

58%—Big Shots (ABC)

57%—Moonlight (CBS), additional episodes ordered

56%—Reaper (CW), additional episodes ordered

50%—Women's Murder Club (ABC)

47%—Aliens in America (CW), asked to continue production

46%—Private Practice (ABC), full season ordered

44%—Dirty Sexy Money (ABC), additional episodes ordered

35%—Bionic Woman (NBC), additional episodes ordered

34%—Journeyman (NBC), additional episodes ordered

29%—Life (NBC), additional episodes ordered

29%—Life Is Wild (CW)

28%—Back to You (Fox), full season ordered

25%—The Big Bang Theory (CBS), full season ordered

25%—Carpoolers (ABC), additional episodes ordered

21%—Cane (CBS), additional episodes ordered

20%—K-Ville (Fox)

15%—Kid Nation (CBS)

13%—Cavemen (ABC)

10%—Viva Laughlin (CBS), canceled

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share

We and our partners use cookies on this site to improve our service, perform analytics, personalize advertising, measure advertising performance, and remember website preferences. By using the site, you consent to these cookies. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our Cookie Policy.