1/11
Paula Lobo/Walt Disney Television via Getty Images
Despite dating multiple women in his lifetime, the Bachelor star still questions his sexuality. He said it began in high school when he dated a girl who wanted to go further than he was willing. This forced him to dump her without explanation, causing a flurry of rumors that he was gay. Speculation grew so rampant it eventually got to his mother who told him one day, "You know, Colt, we'd still love you and support you if you were gay." Brushing off the conjecture, he stuck to his guns and maintained his virginity even as he joined the NFL. When he did tell his teammates about his track record, none questioned his motivations, although one quipped, "Underwood, man, I know someone who can help fix that."