Jackie Evancho as Kitty
No offense to Jackie Evancho, but...who? Apparently she was on America's Got Talent but we could not have told you that when she took off her mask.
Mark Sanchez as the Baby Alien
So sorry to Mark Sanchez but we did not immediately know who he was when he took off his elaborate Baby Alien puppet situation. That seems to always happen to us with the sports stars.
Tommy Chong as the Pineapple
Few things have been more obvious in life than the fact that Tommy Chong was the Pineapple, in a good way. Tommy Chong knows his brand.
Antonio Brown as the Hippo
This was the show's very first reveal back in season one and don't worry if you totally forgot it ever happened, because we did too!
Paul Anka as Broccoli
We're really sorry but when we hear Paul Anka, we think of Gilmore Girls and Lorelai's dog. That is entirely Gilmore Girls' fault. So sorry.
Terry Bradshaw as the Deer
If we were Terry Bradshaw we would wear this costume around our house because it really just works for him.
Paul Shaffer as the Skeleton
Paul Shaffer really embodied that Skeleton and that kooky Skeleton really represented the essence of Paul Shaffer. They feel one in the same.
Dr. Drew as the Eagle
Once upon a time, Dr. Drew Pinsky was dressed as an Eagle singing Meatloaf. Feels like more of a fever dream than something that actually happened.
Barry Zito as the Rhino
Recently someone was talking about Barry Zito for some reason and we were like "Oh my god, the Rhino?!" At least he made some kind of impact on us!
Rumer Willis as the Lion
We all knew the Lion was Rumer from day one, but this still would have been way more exciting if she hadn't had to awkwardly deny it so many times.
Tori Spelling as the Unicorn
Tori Spelling on The Masked Singer just feels right, and thus not all that shocking.
Ninja as the Ice Cream
Honestly, justice for Ice Cream and Egg. They got unmasked in the same season two premiere episode and it really took the excitement out of both of them a little bit. Sorry for Ice Cream, but Egg wins here just because the Egg was a truly insane costume we were all obsessed with before the season premiered.
Lonzo Ball as Whatchamacallit
Basketball player Lonzo Ball did not knock our socks off but it was nice to see him.
Taylor Dayne as Popcorn
Taylor Dayne is a name we hadn't heard in a while so it was sort of exciting to be reminded that she exists and so do hit songs like "Tell It To My Heart."
Bret Michaels as the Banana
"Bret Michaels is the Banana" is absolutely one of the funnier sentences to come out of this show.
Aloe Blacc as Mushroom
Mushroom was such a mystery all season and he was so talented that it was just exciting to find out who he was. Aloe Blacc is not exactly the biggest celebrity but dang he's got some pipes!