For the second season of his Up and Vanished podcast, host Payne Lindsey chose to investigate the bizarre disappearance of another woman, a mom who was allegedly last seen at a full moon drum circle in the small and spiritual town of Crestone, Colorado.
Throughout the season, Lindsey talked to her ex-boyfriend and the father of her young daughter, her landlord, her friends, as well as the group of men Kristal was hanging out with shortly before she went missing in 2016.
By the end of the podcast's second season, Lindsey had a pretty good theory of what happened, suspecting a small circle of friends, including a man named Catfish, at the very least knew something.
"I definitely think Kristal's case can be solved, I think it's going to take some time though," Lindsey said on the podcast.
And his final words in season two? "We've seen a lot come to light in a short amount of time. All I can say is, good luck hiding this forever, guys. The clock is ticking."
Lindsey will continue to investigate the case in season two of Oxygen's Up and Vanished.