• Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Pitch, Man With a Plan, Conviction, The Good Place

Fox; CBS; ABC; NBC

It's here, it's here. No, not pumpkin season, but the fall TV season!

While Dancing With the Stars officially kicks off the 2016 season tonight, the first new show to make it debut will be Kevin Can Wait on Monday, Sept. 19, and like Kevin James, we couldn't wait to share our ranking of ALL the newbies coming to the small screen. We shared our thoughts on all of them in our Rapid-Fire Reviews (ABC, CBS, Fox, NBC and The CW), and now, we ranked them from worst to best. 

So what show snagged our top spot? Was it Kiefer Sutherland's new drama, Designated Survivor? Or maybe Kristen Bell's The Good Place? There's only one way to find out: by clicking through our official ranking below. And make sure to check back with us all season long as we're also going to be asking you to weigh in on the new shows...