Who looks fine, and who should be fined?

Angie vs. Mariah: When "Who Wore It Best" Is No Longer a Contest

Mon., Oct. 6, 2008 10:06 AM PDT by Jennifer Cady

Andrew H. Walker/Getty Images; Denise Truscello/Getty Images

Poor Mariah. This really isn’t fair at all, is it?

Despite being “hampered by a gorgeous face” as Clint Eastwood put it, Angie still managed to rock the red carpet in Versace for The Changeling premiere Saturday night.

She looked smoking—showing off two new tattoos in honor of newcomers Viv and Knox, while talking about plans for future babies.

Meanwhile, Mariah Carey wore the same Versace LBD last night—only shorter, with tights (why?) and black peep toes—to host an evening at the Bellagio’s Bank in Las Vegas.

The only thing worse than wearing the same dress as Angie is wearing it horribly. But if you still feel like there's a possibility Mariah wore it better, do let us know.