Who looks fine, and who should be fined?

When a Starlet and an Icon Wear the Same Dress: Brenda Walsh vs. L.C.

Fri., Sep. 5, 2008 2:36 PM PDT by Jennifer Cady

Jean Baptiste Lacroix / Getty Images ; Jeffrey Ufberg / Getty Images

Lauren Conrad and Shannen Doherty stepped out last night in the same dress. Sure, it was on different coasts (the 90210 star was in NYC for the Late Show) and in different colors, but that doesn’t mean we’d let it slip past us.

We actually feel pretty sorry for L.C. in this fashion face-off—Shannen Doherty is no one we’d like to take on, even if it’s just over who wore a dress best. After all, there may not have been an all-out fistfight between Brenda and Kelly during the original 90210, but there was definitely some scratching.

So you tell us: Which L.A. girl rocked this little silk dress with the fossil print the best? Also, when do you think the 90210-ers will run into the Hills girls at some hot club? Because that's gonna be an awesome showdown.