Yoko Ono Imagines Legal Defeat
Chris Farina/WireImage.com
Like the rest of us, Yoko Ono has to live in a world that's one with the fair-use doctrine.
John Lennon's widow has lost her bid to keep 15 seconds of her late husband's song "Imagine" out of a documentary about scientists and educators who support the theory of intelligent design as an alternative to evolution.
Ono, son Sean Lennon and publisher EMI Blackwood Music Inc., which holds the rights to all of Lennon's music, sued the makers of Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed in federal court last month, arguing that the unsanctioned use of "Imagine" in their film implied that the family had willingly licensed the song.
"Internet 'bloggers' immediately began accusing Mrs. Lennon of 'selling out' by licensing the song to defendants," Ono's suit charged.
But U.S. District Judge Sidney Stein agreed with the defendants that their use of Lennon's most revered solo tune was allowable under the fair-use doctrine, which "provides that the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes of criticism and commentary is not an infringement of copyright."
"They put the song to a different purpose, selected an excerpt containing the ideas they wished to critique, paired the music and lyrics with images that contrast with the song's utopian expression, and placed the excerpt in the context of a debate regarding the role of religion in the public life," Stein wrote in his decision.
Ono has said she will appeal the ruling.
The Big Picture
Ooh La La! Rob arrives in Paris to promote New Moon...and brings some extra sparkle to the City of Light
More PhotosMost Commented
- Would Kristen Work With Rob Outside of Twilight? (861)
- "Exhausted" Rob and Kristen (Kinda) Get Personal (764)
- Robsten Begin Publicity Tour Together—Kinda (605)
- Did Rob Come Across Badly in Vanity Fair? (599)
- Is the Pressure Getting to Robsten? (571)
- "Puppy Dog" Rob and Kristen Play the Newlywed Game (510)
- Overworked Rob Needs a Break! (375)
- Blab Blab Blab: Robsten Ain't Outta Thin Air (354)
- Rob and Kristen Keep the Mystery Going (327)
- Bitch-Back! Angelina Bouncing From Man to Man? (250)
Top 10 Stories
- More Lindsay Tapes Leak: She Was "Dating" Heath at Time of Death, Has "Problem With Her DNA"
- Ugly Betty May Steal Eastwick Slot From Lost
- Carrie Prejean on Solo Sexy Tape: "I'm Humiliated to Be Talking About This Now on National TV"
- Mya Finally Impresses All Three Judges on Dancing With the Stars
- James Woods Takes Brother's Death to Trial
- Katt Williams Not So Funny When He's Arrested for Burglary
- Justin Timberlake Puts the Brakes on "Obsessed, Mentally Unstable" Woman
- D.A.: Sean Penn's Pap Smack Not a Felony Matter
- Singing Burglar Suspect in Protective Custody
- Kelly Osbourne: Why I Won't Weigh Myself
Fashion Police
Sloppy SuitingPoor Eva is a mess from head to skirt at the New York City premiere of her latest flick
More Photos
Latest Movie Reviews
Get Your E! News Now
3 Comments
-
Show the next 1 - 0 of 3 comments
Now loading...