RETURNS
MAY 23, 8PM
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Claudia Levy, Kiernan Shipka

Frederick M. Brown, Donato Sardella/Getty Images

We had one of those, wait, didn't we just see that dress? moments when we caught a glimpse of Claudia Levy in her super cute Mary Katrantzou. Turns out we were almost right. Kiernan Shipka donned an almost identical design at a recent InStyle event to what the Palo Alto star wore at a Hollywood premiere.

Outside of the color combos, this is two fresh-faced rising starlets in the exact same fashion. Luckily they're wearing different shoes to help our decision.

At left is the brunette beauty in a sea of pinks and greens. We love those light colors against her deep hair and peach and cream skin, and we really love the contrast between a light blush on top and deeper color palette below. But the white bootie shoes are a very awkward choice.

The incredible Sally Draper nails it with ocean blues and fresh grass green, but we do miss the light/dark combo that Claudia's selection showcases. And yet the Mad Men star kills it with her perfect summer sandal.

So do we pick color or overall style? Color...and Kiernan. What's your say?

Tune-in to a brand new Fashion Police tonight at 9/8c on E!