Fashion Face-Off: Katy Perry, Britney Spears and Ashley Tisdale in Smurfs 2 Blue

Three singing superstars battle it out in sky-shade styles

By Jessie Rosen Jul 29, 2013 6:55 PMTags
Katy Perry, Britney Spears, Ashley TisdaleCourtesy of SPE, Inc./Michael Buckner; Valerie Macon/Getty Images

It's awfully kind for these A-listers to support the famous blue cartoons through their fashions—especially since blue isn't the most flattering color...

Still, Katy Perry, Britney Spears and Ashley Tisdale stepped out in varying versions of the little blue dress. Were they all trying to pull of their best Smurfette? Though, we're not so sure the famous female from Smurf Village would approve of any of these looks...

The "Fireworks" singer's Tadashi Shoji frock is definitely the most formal of the bunch, which makes sense for the voice of Smurfette. We love the illusion detail on top, even if it does look a bit like a figure skater's costume. We do not love that leather flared skirt, even if it is unique.

Brit's body-hugging blue is a far sexier style—a sort of "Smurfette sneaks out of the house" look. For us it's also way too much of a throwback to the late '90s—a decade we'd prefer to forget, fashion-wise.

And finally there's the Scary Movie star in a the sundress version of Katy's same shade. The underwater embellishment on the bodice are fun, and the black boots are funky. The only weird thing about this look is that Ashley isn't even at the Smurf's 2 premiere!

We're going to give it to Katy, the "real" Smurfette of this bunch. What's your say?

Poll

A Fashion Police July 29th Poll

Which celeb wears her blue best?
Katy!
14.7%
Britney!
63.3%
Ashley!
22%