We're not sure that silver lining stacks up given how much this bondage-style Versace LBD has been photographed on the two starlets. They might as well have been in the same place! We're not surprised to see the former Disney darling or current CW stand-out in this strappy mini. Both have a definite edge to their design choices.
The question is, who brings the heat to this already hot look?
We're big fans of Miley's simple, point pump, but something about the added neck piece on her version of the dress is a little too collar-inspired for our tastes. Kat's booties are a big much on the bottom, but her choice of length on the skirt is classier than the one-time kid star.
What's your say?