The bad news is that we're disappointed that R.Pattz isn't sparkling under all those lights. We're pleased, however, that Lautner still owns at least one shirt that hasn't been shredded by his knife-sharp werewolf pecs.
As for the outfits, well, they're both just sort of meh for us. The plaid on Pattz is fine, neither here nor there as tartans go. The jacket's sort of goth varsity...or something. It's acceptable. Ditto with Lautner's perfectly serviceable shirt and pants.
So, when it comes to supernatural man candy, do you have a preference?