Not include Princess Bride on our list? Inconceivable! This hilarious and highly quotable swashbuckler also boasts one of the sweetest fairytale love stories. A pre-Saw Cary Elwes stars as the dashing pirate (and former stable boy) Westley, while a pre-Penn Robin Wright plays his true love, Buttercup, who must be rescued from an evil prince. We asked for a royal rollicking romance, and director Rob Reiner said, "As you wish."